16,374
edits
Tashlumin: Difference between revisions
From Halachipedia
→If One Forgot to Say Ten Tal Umatar Lbracha on Friday Afternoon
| Line 48: | Line 48: | ||
# If Rosh Chodesh was a Friday then one shouldn’t do Tashlumin on Shabbat since one may not recite voluntary prayers on Shabbat.<Ref>Mishna Brurah 108:36</ref> | # If Rosh Chodesh was a Friday then one shouldn’t do Tashlumin on Shabbat since one may not recite voluntary prayers on Shabbat.<Ref>Mishna Brurah 108:36</ref> | ||
==If One Forgot to Say Ten Tal Umatar Lbracha on Friday Afternoon== | ==If One Forgot to Say Ten Tal Umatar Lbracha on Friday Afternoon== | ||
# If someone forgot to say Ten Tal Umatar Lbracha on Friday afternoon in mincha and only realized after it was too late for mincha some say that one should repeat say Tashlumin at Arvit of Shabbat to fulfill his obligation of Mincha.<ref>Rav Chaim Soloveitchik (Brachot 26b) wrote that the dispute in Tosfot regarding Yaaleh Veyavo is only relevant there since perhaps a Shemona Esrei without Yaaleh Veyavo counts and if one doesn't gain by repeating Shemona Esrei there's no point to say Tashlumin, however, Ten Tal Umatar Lbracha is integral to the Shemona Esrei and if one forgot it it is as though one didn't pray at all.</ref> Others hold that one shouldn't repeat the Shemona Esrei at Arvit since one doesn't gain saying Ten Tal Umatar Lbracha in the Tashlumin Shemona Esrei.<ref>Har Tzvi 54</ref> | # If someone forgot to say Ten Tal Umatar Lbracha on Friday afternoon in mincha and only realized after it was too late for mincha some say that one should repeat say Tashlumin at Arvit of Shabbat to fulfill his obligation of Mincha.<ref>Rav Chaim Soloveitchik (Brachot 26b) wrote that the dispute in Tosfot regarding Yaaleh Veyavo is only relevant there since perhaps a Shemona Esrei without Yaaleh Veyavo counts and if one doesn't gain by repeating Shemona Esrei there's no point to say Tashlumin, however, Ten Tal Umatar Lbracha is integral to the Shemona Esrei and if one forgot it it is as though one didn't pray at all.</ref> Others hold that one shouldn't repeat the Shemona Esrei at Arvit since one doesn't gain saying Ten Tal Umatar Lbracha in the Tashlumin Shemona Esrei.<ref>Har Tzvi 54, Rav Shlomo Zalman Auerbach (Halichot Shlomo 8 fnt. 82) cited by Dirshu 108:73</ref> | ||
==Mourner== | ==Mourner== | ||
