Bots, Bureaucrats, Interface administrators, Suppressors, Administrators, wiki-admin, wiki-controller, wiki-editor, wiki-reader
1,206
edits
Talk:Acquiring Rights to a Mitzvah: Difference between revisions
From Halachipedia
Talk:Acquiring Rights to a Mitzvah (view source)
Revision as of 14:13, 19 February 2024
, 19 Februaryno edit summary
(Created page with "What right does a person have to a mitzvah? Here are some approaches and sources on the topic. * There is no real acquisition on a mitzvah or honor but it isn’t respectful t...") |
No edit summary |
||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
What right does a person have to a mitzvah? Here are some approaches and sources on the topic. | What right does a person have to a mitzvah? Here are some approaches and sources on the topic. | ||
* There is no real acquisition on a mitzvah or honor but it isn’t respectful to take away a position that someone already has. Source: Mishna Gittin 59b, Yoma 12b, Macot 13a. Shulchan Aruch OC 53:25, 153:22, Rama CM 149:31, YD 245:22 | * There is no real acquisition on a mitzvah or honor, but it isn’t respectful to take away a position that someone already has and in some instances it is rabbinically forbidden to take it away. Source: Mishna Gittin 59b, Yoma 12b, Macot 13a. Shulchan Aruch OC 53:25, 153:22, Rama CM 149:31, YD 245:22 | ||
** Maharik 113 understands that it is obvious that someone who did a mitzvah previously is entitled to do it again unless someone else has a good reason to change that. Implied in his words is that a person has a rabbinic “acquisition” of the right to do the honor, similar to the other institutions of the Mishna Gittin 59a. | ** Maharik 113 understands that it is obvious that someone who did a mitzvah previously is entitled to do it again unless someone else has a good reason to change that. Implied in his words is that a person has a rabbinic “acquisition” of the right to do the honor, similar to the other institutions of the Mishna Gittin 59a. | ||
** Ravdaz 4:11 writes that it is a chazaka to do a mitzvah and it is a fortiori from the concept of not switching the eruv from one house to another. | ** Ravdaz 4:11 writes that it is a chazaka to do a mitzvah and it is a fortiori from the concept of not switching the eruv from one house to another. | ||
