16,374
edits
Taking Interest: Difference between revisions
From Halachipedia
→Supplier of a Commodity at a Future Date
| Line 66: | Line 66: | ||
# A person pays for a future of a commodity. At the time for the supplier to deliver the commodity if they agree to exchange the commodity for another commodity it is permitted to do so as long as the supplier already owns the commodity.<ref>Rav Oshiya on 63a</ref> | # A person pays for a future of a commodity. At the time for the supplier to deliver the commodity if they agree to exchange the commodity for another commodity it is permitted to do so as long as the supplier already owns the commodity.<ref>Rav Oshiya on 63a</ref> | ||
# Some explain that it is permitted even if the borrower doesn’t have any of that commodity since the deal began as a sale and not a loan.<ref>Rif bava metsia 34b, Nemukei Yosef 34b quoting Rabbenu Chananel and Rav Hai Goan, Rashba 62b s.v. vki, Gra Y.D. 175:10. The Rif explains that as long as the initial transaction was a sale in the future of a commodity and not a loan it is permitted to switch over the first commodity to the second even if the borrower doesn’t have the commodity. </ref> | # Some explain that it is permitted even if the borrower doesn’t have any of that commodity since the deal began as a sale and not a loan.<ref>Rif bava metsia 34b, Nemukei Yosef 34b quoting Rabbenu Chananel and Rav Hai Goan, Rashba 62b s.v. vki, Gra Y.D. 175:10. The Rif explains that as long as the initial transaction was a sale in the future of a commodity and not a loan it is permitted to switch over the first commodity to the second even if the borrower doesn’t have the commodity. </ref> | ||
==Judging by the Time of Stipulation== | ==Judging by the Time of Stipulation== | ||
