99
edits
When Is the Earliest and Latest Time to Pray?: Difference between revisions
From Halachipedia
When Is the Earliest and Latest Time to Pray? (view source)
Revision as of 20:13, 14 July 2024
, 14 July→After Plag HaMincha
| Line 78: | Line 78: | ||
==== After Plag HaMincha ==== | ==== After Plag HaMincha ==== | ||
# According to Rabbi Yehuda, the latest time for ''mincha'' is ''plag hamincha -'' ten- and three-quarter hours. From then on begins the time for ''arvit''. According to Rabbanan, the cutoff point is nightfall.<ref name=":0" /> Halacha allows one to follow either opinion, however, one must be consistent and always follow the same opinion.<ref name=":1" /> Thus, one who is accustomed to ''davening arvit'' before ''shkiya'' must always ''daven mincha'' before ''plag.''<ref>Rama O.C. 233:1</ref> | # According to Rabbi Yehuda, the latest time for ''mincha'' is ''plag hamincha -'' ten- and three-quarter hours. From then on begins the time for ''arvit''. According to Rabbanan, the cutoff point is nightfall.<ref name=":0" /> Halacha allows one to follow either opinion, however, one must be consistent and always follow the same opinion.<ref name=":1" /> Thus, one who is accustomed to ''davening arvit'' before ''shkiya'' must always ''daven mincha'' before ''plag.''<ref>Shulchan Aruch O.C. 233:1, Rama O.C. 233:1</ref> In extenuating circumstances or if one forgot to ''daven mincha'', they may ''daven'' after ''plag;''<ref>Rama O.C. 233:1</ref> however, they should be particular to ''daven arvit'' after ''tzet hakochavim'' on that night.<ref>Mishna Brurah 233:11,13</ref> | ||
# Some write that, even according to Rabbanan, one must ''daven mincha'' before ''plag.<ref>Aruch Hashulchan O.C. 233:4-9</ref>'' This is not the accepted custom. | |||
====After Sunset==== | ====After Sunset==== | ||
#The Gemara relates, that there is a halachic period of time during twilight called ''"bein hashmashot."'' This period of time is, halachically, a mix of day and night. Before that time is | #One who ''davens arvit'' after ''tzet'' may ''daven mincha'' up until ''shkiya.''<ref>The time period of ''bein hashmashot'' may be considered day, thus, If one ''davens arvit'' after ''shkiya'' but before ''tzet'' it would present a contradiction. Igrot Moshe II:60 writes that it may not be a contradiction to ''daven arvit'' at a time when one would no longer ''daven mincha.'' Thus, he writes, that one may ''daven'' with a ''minyan'' that is ''davening arvit'' at that time, if that is his only opportunity to ''daven'' with a ''minyan.'' </ref> | ||
#The Gemara relates, that there is a halachic period of time during twilight called ''"bein hashmashot."'' This period of time is, halachically, a mix of day and night. Before that time it is day and after which it is night.<ref>Gemara Shabbat 34b. There is a dispute there between Rabbi Yehuda Rabbi Nechemia and Rabbi Yosi. Rabbi Yehuda says that ''bein hasmashot'' begins when the sun (''lit.)'' sinks and lasts until the upper part of the eastern sky is dark. Rabbi Nechemia says that ''bein hashmashot'' starts when the sun sinks and lasts for the duration of 0.5 ''mil.'' Rabbi Yosi says that ''bein hasmashot'' lasts for "a blink of an eye". Gemara Shabbat 35b quotes Rav Yehuda in the name of Shmuel that when there is one star it is still day, two stars is ''bein hashmashot'', three stars is night. Gemara Shabbat 35a writes that the halacha is in accordance with both Rabbi Yehuda and Rabbi Yosi. Rif Shabbat Chap.2, Rosh Shabbat Chap 2:23, and others maintain that the halacha follows Shmuel as well. | |||
*These are the bases for the discussion amongst the ''poskim'' as to the time of ''bein hashmashot''. To see how this translates into the common halacha and for a full discussion see Hazmanim B'halacha Chap. 40 </ref> | *These are the bases for the discussion amongst the ''poskim'' as to the time of ''bein hashmashot''. To see how this translates into the common halacha and for a full discussion see Hazmanim B'halacha Chap. 40</ref> | ||
#There is a great dispute regarding the time for ''bein hashmashot'' and the time for ''tzet hakochavim'' with many ramifications in halacha. The ''geonim'' write that ''bein hashmashot'' begins at sunset and lasts for 0.75 ''mil'' at which time it is ''tzet hakochavim.''<ref>Ginzei Kedem V pg.37, See Teshuvat Maharam Alshakar 96 quoting Teshuvat Rav Sherira Goan and Rav Hai Goan. | #There is a great dispute regarding the time for ''bein hashmashot'' and the time for ''tzet hakochavim'' with many ramifications in halacha. The ''geonim'' write that ''bein hashmashot'' begins at sunset and lasts for 0.75 ''mil'' at which time it is ''tzet hakochavim.''<ref>Ginzei Kedem V pg.37, See Teshuvat Maharam Alshakar 96 quoting Teshuvat Rav Sherira Goan and Rav Hai Goan. | ||
| Line 101: | Line 103: | ||
*See Hazmanim B'halacha Chap 41 for a complete discussion.</ref> | *See Hazmanim B'halacha Chap 41 for a complete discussion.</ref> | ||
#Some ''poskim'' write, that even according to Rabbenu Tam, in areas of a lower latitude where three medium-sized stars are visible earlier, ''tzet hakochavim'' would be at the time when the stars are visible.<ref>Minchas Kohen 2:5 ''s.v.'' ''she'im'', Biur Halacha 261:2 ''s.v. kodem'' and Igros Moshe O.C. IV:62 agree. Rav Moshe writes that in New York the time for ''tzet'' according to Rabbenu Tam is 50 minutes after ''shkiya''; however, he writes that it is proper for G-d fearing Jews to wait 72 minutes to end Shabbat, as was the custom in Europe. See Hazmanim B'halacha Chap. 42 for a complete discussion.</ref> | #Some ''poskim'' write, that even according to Rabbenu Tam, in areas of a lower latitude where three medium-sized stars are visible earlier, ''tzet hakochavim'' would be at the time when the stars are visible.<ref>Minchas Kohen 2:5 ''s.v.'' ''she'im'', Biur Halacha 261:2 ''s.v. kodem'' and Igros Moshe O.C. IV:62 agree. Rav Moshe writes that in New York the time for ''tzet'' according to Rabbenu Tam is 50 minutes after ''shkiya''; however, he writes that it is proper for G-d fearing Jews to wait 72 minutes to end Shabbat, as was the custom in Europe. See Hazmanim B'halacha Chap. 42 for a complete discussion.</ref> | ||
#One must ''daven mincha'' during the daytime. Since ''bein hashmashot'' begins at sunset according to the ''geonim'', one should ''daven mincha'' before sunset. After the fact, opinions differ regarding how late one can still ''daven'', and at what point should instead say [[Tashlumin|''tashlumin'']] at [[Maariv|''maariv'']]. Factors that come into consideration include whether or not one can rely on Rabbenu Tam after the fact, and whether or not one may ''daven'' during ''bein hashmashot'', as it may still be day.<ref>Rav Nevinsal on Mishna Brurah 233:14 writes that someone who doesn't always follow Rabbenu Tam on ending Shabbat can not daven mincha after sunset even after the fact. Also, Avnei Darech 8:200 quotes Rav Shlomo Zalman Auerbach as holding that one may not daven mincha after sunset. [http://www.eretzhemdah.org/newsletterArticle.asp?lang=he&pageid=48&cat=1&newsletter=3705&article=7631 Bmarah Habazek 3:14] writes that one shouldn't daven after sunset and just daven tashlumin. [https://www.yeshiva.co/ask/58222 Rav Belsky] held that it is possible to daven up to 9 minutes after sunset based on Rav Moshe. See Igrot Moshe 1:24 who writes that one shouldn't pray mincha after sunset. See further Igrot Moshe 4:62. Piskei Teshuvot 233:8 writes that the Minhag in Eretz Yisrael is that one may lenient to Daven mincha during Bein Hashmashot (according to the opinion of the Ge'onim) which is up to 13 and one half minutes after shkia'ah.</ref> | #One must ''daven mincha'' during the daytime. Since ''bein hashmashot'' begins at sunset according to the ''geonim'', one should ''daven mincha'' before sunset. After the fact, opinions differ regarding how late one can still ''daven'', and at what point should instead say [[Tashlumin|''tashlumin'']] at [[Maariv|''maariv'']]. Factors that come into consideration include whether or not one can rely on Rabbenu Tam after the fact, and whether or not one may ''daven'' during ''bein hashmashot'', as it may still be day.<ref>Rav Nevinsal on Mishna Brurah 233:14 writes that someone who doesn't always follow Rabbenu Tam on ending Shabbat can not daven mincha after sunset even after the fact. Also, Avnei Darech 8:200 quotes Rav Shlomo Zalman Auerbach as holding that one may not daven mincha after sunset. [http://www.eretzhemdah.org/newsletterArticle.asp?lang=he&pageid=48&cat=1&newsletter=3705&article=7631 Bmarah Habazek 3:14] writes that one shouldn't daven after sunset and just daven tashlumin. [https://www.yeshiva.co/ask/58222 Rav Belsky] held that it is possible to daven up to 9 minutes after sunset based on Rav Moshe. See Igrot Moshe 1:24 who writes that one shouldn't pray mincha after sunset. See further Igrot Moshe 4:62. Piskei Teshuvot 233:8 writes that the Minhag in Eretz Yisrael is that one may lenient to Daven mincha during Bein Hashmashot (according to the opinion of the Ge'onim) which is up to 13 and one half minutes after shkia'ah.</ref><ref>To illustrate this point: Igrot Moshe IV:62 writes that the first nine minutes after ''shkiya'' are considered a ''sfek sfaika and'' regarding a ''bris milah'' we would cosider the baby to be born on the earlier day. The ''sfek sfaika'' is that maybe the halacha follows Rabbenu Tam, and even not, it may be day even according to the ''geonim.'' (Rav Moshe calculates that ''tzet hakochavim'' of the ''geonim,'' in New York, is nine minutes after ''shkiya'').</ref> | ||
#Many Chassidim maintain that it is optimal to ''daven'' ''mincha'' up until the ''bein hashmashot'' of Rabbenu Tam, which is | #Many Chassidim maintain that it is optimal to ''daven'' ''mincha'' up until the ''bein hashmashot'' of Rabbenu Tam, which is 3.75 ''mil'' after ''shkiya''. There are some who hold that it is even optimal to ''daven'' during ''bein hashmashot'' of Rabbenu Tam.<ref>For a discussion on this see Piskei Teshuva 233:6-8.</ref> | ||
#If one's only options are to either to ''daven'' ''mincha'' before sunset himself or to ''daven'' with a ''minyan'' after sunset, it will depend on if he is Ashkenazi or Sephardi. Ashkenazim hold that one should ''daven'' oneself on time before sunset,<ref>Mishna Brurah 233:14 writes that it is better to pray Mincha before shkiyah without a minyan than to pray with a minyan after shkiyah. In an extenuating circumstance he allows davening mincha until 3.25 mil after shekiya based on the Shulchan Aruch. [https://ph.yhb.org.il/02-24-04/#_te01ftn24_3 Peninei Halacha (Tefillah 24:4)] holds that one can follow the Mishna Brurah who is based on Rabbenu Tam and even though we do not follow Rabbenu Tam since many agree with him. However, Kuntres Seyda Lderech p. 39 quotes Chazon Ish that one should not daven mincha after sunset even in extenuating circumstances or after the fact. Dirshu 233:22 cites this as well from Ishrei Yosher (Nezikin n. 94). Rav Nevinsal on Mishna Brurah 233:14 writes that someone who doesn't always follow Rabbenu Tam on ending Shabbat can not daven mincha after sunset even after the fact. Also, Avnei Darech 8:200 quotes Rav Shlomo Zalman Auerbach as holding that one may not daven mincha after sunset. [http://www.eretzhemdah.org/newsletterArticle.asp?lang=he&pageid=48&cat=1&newsletter=3705&article=7631 Bmarah Habazek 3:14] writes that one shouldn't daven after sunset and just daven tashlumin. [https://www.yeshiva.co/ask/58222 Rav Belsky] held that it is possible to daven up to 9 minutes after sunset based on Rav Moshe. See Igrot Moshe 1:24 who writes that one shouldn't pray mincha after sunset. See further Igrot Moshe 4:62.</ref> while Sephardim hold that one can wait to ''daven'' with the ''minyan'' as long as it is within 13.5 minutes after sunset.<ref> Chacham Ben Zion Abba Shaul (cited in Ishei Yisroel page 296) and Chacham Ovadia Yosef (Yechave Daat 5:22) write that it is preferable to pray with a minyan as long as they are praying within the first thirteen and a half minutes after sunset. Rabbi Meir Mazuz in Bayit Neeman 1:25 p. 146 s.v. miyhu agrees even though we don't accept Rabbeinu Tam since this case is an minhag to pray during Ben Hashemashot. Yalkut Yosef 233:3 and Halacha Brurah 233:6 agree. </ref> | #If one's only options are to either to ''daven'' ''mincha'' before sunset himself or to ''daven'' with a ''minyan'' after sunset, it will depend on if he is Ashkenazi or Sephardi. Ashkenazim hold that one should ''daven'' oneself on time before sunset,<ref>Mishna Brurah 233:14 writes that it is better to pray Mincha before shkiyah without a minyan than to pray with a minyan after shkiyah. In an extenuating circumstance he allows davening mincha until 3.25 mil after shekiya based on the Shulchan Aruch. [https://ph.yhb.org.il/02-24-04/#_te01ftn24_3 Peninei Halacha (Tefillah 24:4)] holds that one can follow the Mishna Brurah who is based on Rabbenu Tam and even though we do not follow Rabbenu Tam since many agree with him. However, Kuntres Seyda Lderech p. 39 quotes Chazon Ish that one should not daven mincha after sunset even in extenuating circumstances or after the fact. Dirshu 233:22 cites this as well from Ishrei Yosher (Nezikin n. 94). Rav Nevinsal on Mishna Brurah 233:14 writes that someone who doesn't always follow Rabbenu Tam on ending Shabbat can not daven mincha after sunset even after the fact. Also, Avnei Darech 8:200 quotes Rav Shlomo Zalman Auerbach as holding that one may not daven mincha after sunset. [http://www.eretzhemdah.org/newsletterArticle.asp?lang=he&pageid=48&cat=1&newsletter=3705&article=7631 Bmarah Habazek 3:14] writes that one shouldn't daven after sunset and just daven tashlumin. [https://www.yeshiva.co/ask/58222 Rav Belsky] held that it is possible to daven up to 9 minutes after sunset based on Rav Moshe. See Igrot Moshe 1:24 who writes that one shouldn't pray mincha after sunset. See further Igrot Moshe 4:62.</ref> while Sephardim hold that one can wait to ''daven'' with the ''minyan'' as long as it is within 13.5 minutes after sunset.<ref> Chacham Ben Zion Abba Shaul (cited in Ishei Yisroel page 296) and Chacham Ovadia Yosef (Yechave Daat 5:22) write that it is preferable to pray with a minyan as long as they are praying within the first thirteen and a half minutes after sunset. Rabbi Meir Mazuz in Bayit Neeman 1:25 p. 146 s.v. miyhu agrees even though we don't accept Rabbeinu Tam since this case is an minhag to pray during Ben Hashemashot. Yalkut Yosef 233:3 and Halacha Brurah 233:6 agree. </ref> | ||
| Line 132: | Line 134: | ||
*Rashi Brachot 26a s.v. Ad Chashecha according to Shaagat Aryeh 17, Ra'av Brachot 4:1, and others explain "nightfall" to be ''tzet hakochavim.'' See Zemanim B'Halachah - Rav Benish Chap 34:7 and footnotes 22-28. | *Rashi Brachot 26a s.v. Ad Chashecha according to Shaagat Aryeh 17, Ra'av Brachot 4:1, and others explain "nightfall" to be ''tzet hakochavim.'' See Zemanim B'Halachah - Rav Benish Chap 34:7 and footnotes 22-28. | ||
*Rama O.C. 233:1 writes that according to the Rabbanan one may ''daven mincha'' until ''tzet hakochavim''. Shulchan Aruch O.C. 233:1 writes that the ''minhag'' is to ''daven mincha'' until ''shkiya'' and one may not ''daven arvit'' before ''shkiya''. Mishna Brurah 233:8,9,14 understands that Shulchan Aruch means the second ''shkiya'' and that Shulchan Aruch and Rama both agree that one may ''daven mincha'' up until Rabbenu Tam's ''bein hashmashot'' which is | *Rama O.C. 233:1 writes that according to the Rabbanan one may ''daven mincha'' until ''tzet hakochavim''. | ||
*Shulchan Aruch O.C. 233:1 writes that the ''minhag'' is to ''daven mincha'' until ''shkiya'' and one may not ''daven arvit'' before ''shkiya''. | |||
*Mishna Brurah 233:8,9,14 understands that Shulchan Aruch means the second ''shkiya'' and that Shulchan Aruch and Rama both agree that one may ''daven mincha'' up until Rabbenu Tam's ''bein hashmashot'' which is 3.25 ''mil'' after sunset. That which Shulchan Aruch and Rama write ''"shkiya"'' and "''tzet hakochavim"'' is not exact and means "almost up until that time." Mishna Brurah understands that the cutoff of the Rabbanan is ''tzet'' but since ''bein hashmashot'' is a time of ''safek'', one may not ''daven'' neither ''mincha'' nor ''arvit'' during that time. Thus, ''mincha'' must be recited before 3.25 ''mil'' after sunset and ''arvit'' must be recited after 4 ''mil''. However, the Mishna Brurah, quoting many ''poskim,'' see Shaar Hatziyun 233:18, writes that others argue on the Shulchan Aruch and Rama and according to them one must not ''daven mincha'' after ''shkiya.'' The Mishna Brurah 233:14 writes that one should be stringent in accordance with this view. Nevertheless, he adds that one who is under extreme duress may be lenient to ''daven'' until 3.25 ''mil'' after ''shkiya'', but should ''daven'' as early as possible so as not to enter into a ''safek shkiya''. | |||
*Mishna Brurah 235:12 writes that it is optimal to ''daven arvit'' after ''tzet'' - earlier than that, during ''bein hashmashot,'' is a ''safek''. Biur Halacha 233:1 ''s.v. d'haynu'' writes that one who is ''davening'' ''mincha'' after ''shkiya'' should make a condition: if this is still the time for ''mincha'' then this ''tefilla'' will be for ''mincha'' and the next will be for ''arvit''; yet if it is now the time for ''arvit'', this ''tefillah'' will be ''arvit'' and the next one will be a ''tashlumin'' for ''mincha.'' | |||
*Aruch HaShulchan 233:6-9 writes that one who is able must ''daven mincha'' before ''plag''. One who is not able to ''daven'' then must be careful to ''daven'' before ''shkiya'', despite the fact that there are ''rishonim'' who say that one may ''daven'' until ''tzet''. | |||
*Igrot Moshe I:24 writes in accordance with Mishna Brura that one should not ''daven mincha'' after ''shkiya'' unless under duress. Rav Moshe adds that in America the ''zman'' of Rabbenu Tam is certainly less than an hour after ''shkiya.'' Thus, taking ''bein hashmashot'' into account, the time for ''mincha'' cannot be later than 48 minutes after ''shkiya'', and possibly it is in fact earlier. | |||
*Orchot Rabbeinu III pg. 225 quotes the Chazon Ish as saying that if one knows that he won't finish ''shemoneh esrei'' before ''shkiya'' then he should not start ''davening''; rather he should ''daven'' ''maariv shemoneh esrei'' twice as ''tashlumin.'' | |||
</ref> In extenuating circumstances, one may ''daven arvit'' before sunset if on that day he ''davened mincha'' before ''plag hamincha''. Although he usually follows the Rabbanan, it is considered as if on that day he followed Rabbi Yehuda.<ref>The Rabbenu Yonah (18b s.v. DeAved) writes that one should always follow Rabbanan (which was the minhag of his time and place) but nonetheless, after the fact if one prayed [[Arvit]] after Plag [[Mincha]] one has fulfilled one’s obligation. This is quoted in Bet Yosef 233:1 and codified in Shulchan Aruch O.C. 233:1. The Shulchan Aruch 233:1 rules that in extenuating circumstances one may pray [[Arvit]] before nighttime even though one always follows Rabbanan. Mishna Brurah 233:11 writes that this is only permissible if that day itself one already prayed [[Mincha]] prior to ten and three quarter hours.</ref> | </ref> In extenuating circumstances, one may ''daven arvit'' before sunset if on that day he ''davened mincha'' before ''plag hamincha''. Although he usually follows the Rabbanan, it is considered as if on that day he followed Rabbi Yehuda.<ref>The Rabbenu Yonah (18b s.v. DeAved) writes that one should always follow Rabbanan (which was the minhag of his time and place) but nonetheless, after the fact if one prayed [[Arvit]] after Plag [[Mincha]] one has fulfilled one’s obligation. This is quoted in Bet Yosef 233:1 and codified in Shulchan Aruch O.C. 233:1. The Shulchan Aruch 233:1 rules that in extenuating circumstances one may pray [[Arvit]] before nighttime even though one always follows Rabbanan. Mishna Brurah 233:11 writes that this is only permissible if that day itself one already prayed [[Mincha]] prior to ten and three quarter hours.</ref> | ||
#If the only minyan for ''arvit'' ''davens'' before sunset, after ''plag hamincha,'' one should daven with them<ref>The Biur Halacha 235:1 cites the Gra who held that it is better to daven privately on time rather than daven with the congregation early. However, in Shaar Hatziyun 235:16 he quotes the Derech Hachayim that if one prayed mincha before plag and the only option is to daven after plag maariv with a minyan or after tzeit without a minyan, it is better to daven with a minyan after plag. If he didn't daven ''mincha'' until after ''plag'', it is better to ''daven maariv'' oneself than to daven in a minyan before sunset and contradict oneself within one day.</ref> and repeat ''shema'' after ''tzet hakochavim''. Some say to skip ''birchot kriyat shema'' and recite them after ''tzet hakochavim'' with ''shema''.<ref>Rabbenu Yonah Brachot 1b writes that if the congregation is davening before the time for Shema one should daven with them even though he won't fulfill his obligation of ''shema'' and will have to repeat it later. He then quotes Rav Hai Goan who says that one should only say ''shema'' with them without kavana to fulfill one's obligation but skip birchot kriyat shema. The Shulchan Aruch OC 235:1 rules like the Rabbenu Yonah but the Mishna Brurah 235:12 mentions the practice of the Rav Hai Goan. Rav Moshe Feinstein in Igrot Moshe OC 2:60 agrees that one can follow either opinion whether to daven everything or just Shema without kavana and Shemona Esrei and then say Shema with Kriyat Shema with Brachot afterwards. He writes that one shouldn't follow the Gra unless one always does according to his opinion.</ref> | #If the only minyan for ''arvit'' ''davens'' before sunset, after ''plag hamincha,'' one should daven with them<ref>The Biur Halacha 235:1 cites the Gra who held that it is better to daven privately on time rather than daven with the congregation early. However, in Shaar Hatziyun 235:16 he quotes the Derech Hachayim that if one prayed mincha before plag and the only option is to daven after plag maariv with a minyan or after tzeit without a minyan, it is better to daven with a minyan after plag. If he didn't daven ''mincha'' until after ''plag'', it is better to ''daven maariv'' oneself than to daven in a minyan before sunset and contradict oneself within one day.</ref> and repeat ''shema'' after ''tzet hakochavim''. Some say to skip ''birchot kriyat shema'' and recite them after ''tzet hakochavim'' with ''shema''.<ref>Rabbenu Yonah Brachot 1b writes that if the congregation is davening before the time for Shema one should daven with them even though he won't fulfill his obligation of ''shema'' and will have to repeat it later. He then quotes Rav Hai Goan who says that one should only say ''shema'' with them without kavana to fulfill one's obligation but skip birchot kriyat shema. The Shulchan Aruch OC 235:1 rules like the Rabbenu Yonah but the Mishna Brurah 235:12 mentions the practice of the Rav Hai Goan. Rav Moshe Feinstein in Igrot Moshe OC 2:60 agrees that one can follow either opinion whether to daven everything or just Shema without kavana and Shemona Esrei and then say Shema with Kriyat Shema with Brachot afterwards. He writes that one shouldn't follow the Gra unless one always does according to his opinion.</ref> | ||
