16,374
edits
Soups: Difference between revisions
From Halachipedia
→Noodles, dumplings, or soup nuts
No edit summary |
|||
| Line 24: | Line 24: | ||
# If there’s a small amount of noodles, kneidlach (dumplings), or soup nuts one makes two [[Brachot]], [[Shehakol]] on the soup and [[Mezonot]] on the noodles. <Ref> Laws of [[Brachos]] (pg 363) writes if there’s a small amount of noodles, kneidlach, or soup nuts one makes two [[Brachot]], [[Shehakol]] on the soup and [[Mezonot]] on the noodles. Similarly, Halachos of Brochos (pg 72, chapter 4, Rabbi Pinchas Bodner) writes that soup nuts enhance the soup and so it requires two [[Brachot]] ([[Mezonot]] and [[Shehakol]]). Vezot HaBracha (pg 117, chapter 12) agrees and says that the same is true of noodles, or dumplings in soup. Vezot HaBracha specifies that this is usually the case when there is a small amount of noodles in the soup. | # If there’s a small amount of noodles, kneidlach (dumplings), or soup nuts one makes two [[Brachot]], [[Shehakol]] on the soup and [[Mezonot]] on the noodles. <Ref> Laws of [[Brachos]] (pg 363) writes if there’s a small amount of noodles, kneidlach, or soup nuts one makes two [[Brachot]], [[Shehakol]] on the soup and [[Mezonot]] on the noodles. Similarly, Halachos of Brochos (pg 72, chapter 4, Rabbi Pinchas Bodner) writes that soup nuts enhance the soup and so it requires two [[Brachot]] ([[Mezonot]] and [[Shehakol]]). Vezot HaBracha (pg 117, chapter 12) agrees and says that the same is true of noodles, or dumplings in soup. Vezot HaBracha specifies that this is usually the case when there is a small amount of noodles in the soup. | ||
* Vezot HaBracha (pg 117) writes that in order to avoid exempting the soup with the [[mezonot]] one should say the [[Shehakol]] before the [[Mezonot]], while the Halachos of [[Brachos]] (pg 72) disagrees saying to make the [[mezonot]] first. </ref> | * Vezot HaBracha (pg 117) writes that in order to avoid exempting the soup with the [[mezonot]] one should say the [[Shehakol]] before the [[Mezonot]], while the Halachos of [[Brachos]] (pg 72) disagrees saying to make the [[mezonot]] first. </ref> | ||
# If there’s a significant amount of noodles, kneidlach (dumplings), or soup nuts, and one is interested just as much in the soup as one is interested in the soup nuts, noodles, or dumplings one should only make [[Mezonot]] and it exempts the soup. <Ref> Vezot HaBracha (pg 118, chapter 12) writes that if there’s a significant amount of soup nuts, noodles, or dumplings, and one is interested just as much in the soup as one is interested in the soup nuts, noodles, or dumplings one should only make [[Mezonot]] and it exempts the soup. Similarly, Laws of [[Brachos]] (pg 363) writes that if there’s a majority of noodles in the soup the Bracha is [[Mezonot]]. </ref> | # If there’s a significant amount of noodles, kneidlach (dumplings), or soup nuts, and one is interested just as much in the soup as one is interested in the soup nuts, noodles, or dumplings one should only make [[Mezonot]] and it exempts the soup. <Ref> Vezot HaBracha (pg 118, chapter 12) writes that if there’s a significant amount of soup nuts, noodles, or dumplings, and one is interested just as much in the soup as one is interested in the soup nuts, noodles, or dumplings one should only make [[Mezonot]] and it exempts the soup. See the Mishna Brurah 205:11 in support of this point. Igrot Moshe 4:43 writes that if there's matzah balls in a soup, one should recite mezonot on the matzah ball and exempt the soup. Similarly, Laws of [[Brachos]] (pg 363) writes that if there’s a majority of noodles in the soup the Bracha is [[Mezonot]]. </ref> | ||
# If one is eating the noodles, kneidlach (dumplings), or soup nuts just because they’re there one only says [[Shehakol]]. <ref> Vezot HaBracha (pg 117, chapter 12) writes that if one is eating the soup nuts, noodles, or dumplings just because they’re there, one should only make [[Shehakol]] on the soup and that exempts the noodles, kneidlach (dumplings), or soup nuts. </ref> | # If one is eating the noodles, kneidlach (dumplings), or soup nuts just because they’re there one only says [[Shehakol]]. <ref> Vezot HaBracha (pg 117, chapter 12) writes that if one is eating the soup nuts, noodles, or dumplings just because they’re there, one should only make [[Shehakol]] on the soup and that exempts the noodles, kneidlach (dumplings), or soup nuts. </ref> | ||
==Matzah Balls== | ==Matzah Balls== | ||
# If there are [[Matzah]] balls in the soup a [[Mezonot]] is made on the [[Matzah]] balls and [[Shehakol]] on the soup because the [[Matzah]] balls are eaten as separate from the soup. <Ref> VeTen Bracha (pg 73, chapter 4). See also Vezot HaBracha (pg 118#6, chapter 11) </ref> | # If there are [[Matzah]] balls in the soup a [[Mezonot]] is made on the [[Matzah]] balls and [[Shehakol]] on the soup because the [[Matzah]] balls are eaten as separate from the soup. <Ref> VeTen Bracha (pg 73, chapter 4). See also Vezot HaBracha (pg 118#6, chapter 11) </ref> | ||
