Bots, Bureaucrats, Interface administrators, Suppressors, Administrators, wiki-admin, wiki-controller, wiki-editor, wiki-reader
1,220
edits
Mikvaot: Difference between revisions
From Halachipedia
→Zochlin from Mikveh to Mikveh
| Line 159: | Line 159: | ||
Packet 11 | Packet 11 | ||
Igrot Kehilat Yakov v. 4 siman 10 is machmir against Chazon Ish 127:2 s.v. haya | Igrot Kehilat Yakov v. 4 siman 10 is machmir against Chazon Ish 127:2 s.v. haya | ||
# If the water is filled up to where the hashaka hole and when the woman dips in the mikveh, some water is displaced and spills out of the mikveh into the bor zeriya or bor hashaka. That movement of water could be considered zochlin and invalidate the mikveh.<ref>Chazon Ish (Likkutim 6:2 s.v. haya) himself raised the issue but limited it to where the water would be pouring out of the hole from bor tevila into the bor zeriya or bor hashaka and the water is arched. However, if the water is just dribbling down the side of the walls and not arched then it isn't considered zochlin. He leaves it with tzarich iyun, indicating that he wasn't certain about this point.</ref> What are the solutions? | |||
## Chazon Ish YD 123:1 has solution to put hole lower down. Chelkat Yakov 10:3:53:2, 58:2 and Minchat Yitzchak 2:23 accept this Chazon Ish and actually implemented it in their mikvaot. However, Mikveh Mayim v. 1 p. 27 quotes Rav Greenwald from Papo who holds that this solution is worse. The water coming in from the pipe below makes it zochlin since all of the water can be seen rising and overflowing. Also, it is worse since the zechila is from below 40 seah. Mey Hashilo'ach p. 27. | |||
## Rav Aharon Kotler (mishnat rebbe aharon 24:8, 25:1) held that this isn't an issue at all since zochlin can create hashaka. Rav Moshe agrees. Chazon Ish kama 3:2, igrot 1:112. however, maharsham 1:122 machmir | |||
===Zochlin that isn’t recognizable=== | ===Zochlin that isn’t recognizable=== | ||
