Bots, Bureaucrats, Interface administrators, Suppressors, Administrators, wiki-admin, wiki-controller, wiki-editor, wiki-reader
1,220
edits
Mikvaot: Difference between revisions
From Halachipedia
→Zeriya
(→Zeriya) |
|||
| Line 288: | Line 288: | ||
*Raavan 28 answers that the gemara discussing someone who was tovel there immediately after the sheuvim fell in. That's why there's a concern that the sheuvim are still in one place and retain the status of sheuvim. However, after a half hour or hour the sheuvim get mixed up with the rest of the ocean and are no longer considered sheuvim. Kesef Mishna (Hilchot Mikvaot 6:10) agrees. He says that when pouring sheuvim into a mikveh it gets mixed right away. In Macot, it didn't get mixed right away since the water seeped out of a barrel that fell into the ocean. | *Raavan 28 answers that the gemara discussing someone who was tovel there immediately after the sheuvim fell in. That's why there's a concern that the sheuvim are still in one place and retain the status of sheuvim. However, after a half hour or hour the sheuvim get mixed up with the rest of the ocean and are no longer considered sheuvim. Kesef Mishna (Hilchot Mikvaot 6:10) agrees. He says that when pouring sheuvim into a mikveh it gets mixed right away. In Macot, it didn't get mixed right away since the water seeped out of a barrel that fell into the ocean. | ||
* Tosfot (Macot 4a s.v. amar) explains that the correct text of the gemara should read that it is a barrel of wine and so there's no question about sheuvim at all.</ref> | * Tosfot (Macot 4a s.v. amar) explains that the correct text of the gemara should read that it is a barrel of wine and so there's no question about sheuvim at all.</ref> | ||
#If sheuvim is poured into a complete mikveh and then the sheuvim water flowed into another mikveh, some rishonim hold that the sheuvim water is still kosher as a mikveh.<ref>[https://beta.hebrewbooks.org/reader/reader.aspx?sfid=20319#p=93&fitMode=fitwidth&hlts=&ocr= Rabbenu Yerucham (225d)] cited by Bet Yosef 201:15</ref> Others hold that after the zeriya water flowed into another mikveh they're no longer kosher. It is good to be strict for this view.<ref>Shach 201:41</ref> | |||
#Chatom Sofer YD 2:211 s.v. v'l'inyan distinguishes between zeriya of water into other water and just connecting them through hashaka. | #Chatom Sofer YD 2:211 s.v. v'l'inyan distinguishes between zeriya of water into other water and just connecting them through hashaka. | ||
