Bots, Bureaucrats, Interface administrators, Suppressors, Administrators, wiki-admin, wiki-controller, wiki-editor, wiki-reader
1,220
edits
Mikvaot: Difference between revisions
From Halachipedia
→Joining Mikveh or Using Hashaka with Katafras
| Line 295: | Line 295: | ||
* The Divrei Chaim 2:97 writes that the stairs aren’t connected with the mikveh and one may not be tovel there. Chelkat Yakov YD 111 writes that the Divrei Chaim is completely contradicted by Shulchan Aruch. He writes that perhaps the Divrei Chaim only meant to be strict if the stairs are slanted towards the inside of the mikveh so that no water could remain on them unless the mikveh was full. Either way, he thinks the Divrei Chaim is totally wrong. He ends by quoting a testimony that the Divrei Chaim retracted before he died.</ref> According to those who think that the stairs aren’t connected with the mikveh one should avoid having the hashaka hole on the stairs.<ref>Betzel Chachma 3:80:3</ref> | * The Divrei Chaim 2:97 writes that the stairs aren’t connected with the mikveh and one may not be tovel there. Chelkat Yakov YD 111 writes that the Divrei Chaim is completely contradicted by Shulchan Aruch. He writes that perhaps the Divrei Chaim only meant to be strict if the stairs are slanted towards the inside of the mikveh so that no water could remain on them unless the mikveh was full. Either way, he thinks the Divrei Chaim is totally wrong. He ends by quoting a testimony that the Divrei Chaim retracted before he died.</ref> According to those who think that the stairs aren’t connected with the mikveh one should avoid having the hashaka hole on the stairs.<ref>Betzel Chachma 3:80:3</ref> | ||
#Some rishonim who hold that sheuvim is only derabbanan hold that katafras is a connection to purify sheuvim.<ref>Rash (Mikvaot 6:8)</ref> | #Some rishonim who hold that sheuvim is only derabbanan hold that katafras is a connection to purify sheuvim.<ref>Rash (Mikvaot 6:8)</ref> | ||
#Some say that if water is in a pipe that is on a slant connecting two mikvaot that isn't katafras because the top water will eventually end up in the bottom mikvah.<Ref>The Mishna (Mikvaot 6:8) allows connecting two mikvaot one above the other on a mountain with a pipe. Why isn't that katafras? Rash answers that katafras isn't a problem for sheuvim. Tosfot Yom Tov (Mikvaot 6:8) based on Tosfot Gittin 16a answers that since the water will definitely flow from the upper mikvah to the bottom one it isn't katafras.</reF> | |||
==Tevilah in and on a Kli== | ==Tevilah in and on a Kli== | ||
