16,374
edits
Melechet Machshevet: Difference between revisions
From Halachipedia
→Dvar sheina mitchaven
No edit summary |
|||
| Line 11: | Line 11: | ||
There is a dispute between Rabbi Yehuda and Rabbi Shimon whether performing an action that is a dvar sheina mitchaven is permitted or forbidden. Within the opinion that is forbidden, many assume that it is only a rabbinic prohibition on Shabbos.<ref name="ftn8"> Tosfos 41b s.v. meycham based on Meleches Machsheves, Tosfos Yoma 34b, Rashi 121b s.v. dilma</ref> The halacha is that a dvar sheina mitchaven is completely permitted.<ref name="ftn9"> Based on Rabba’s opinion, the halacha follows Rabbi Shimon that dvar sheina mitchaven is permitted. This is the opinion of all Rishonim and Achronim except for [http://www.hebrewbooks.org/pdfpager.aspx?req=21198&st=&pgnum=127 Rav Yacov Emden in Lechem Shamayim (Beitzah 2:10)]. </ref> | There is a dispute between Rabbi Yehuda and Rabbi Shimon whether performing an action that is a dvar sheina mitchaven is permitted or forbidden. Within the opinion that is forbidden, many assume that it is only a rabbinic prohibition on Shabbos.<ref name="ftn8"> Tosfos 41b s.v. meycham based on Meleches Machsheves, Tosfos Yoma 34b s.v. Hani, Rashi 121b s.v. dilma</ref> The halacha is that a dvar sheina mitchaven is completely permitted.<ref name="ftn9"> Based on Rabba’s opinion, the halacha follows Rabbi Shimon that dvar sheina mitchaven is permitted. This is the opinion of all Rishonim and Achronim except for [http://www.hebrewbooks.org/pdfpager.aspx?req=21198&st=&pgnum=127 Rav Yacov Emden in Lechem Shamayim (Beitzah 2:10)]. </ref> | ||
==Pesik Reisha== | ==Pesik Reisha== | ||
