Bots, Bureaucrats, Interface administrators, Suppressors, Administrators, wiki-admin, wiki-controller, wiki-editor, wiki-reader
1,210
edits
Klalei Halacha: Difference between revisions
From Halachipedia
→Safek Derabbanan Lkula when one didn't do anything
| Line 17: | Line 17: | ||
==Safek Derabbanan Lkula when one didn't do anything== | ==Safek Derabbanan Lkula when one didn't do anything== | ||
# Mishna Lmelech<ref>Bechorot ch. 4</ref> writes that safek derabbanan lkula only applies if he did something to permit the rabbinic prohibition. However, if he did nothing (dvar hamatiro) and there just is a safek, it is forbidden. However, Shaar Hamelech<ref>Mikvaot 10:6:1 and 7</ref> argues. Here are his proofs: | # Mishna Lmelech<ref>Bechorot ch. 4</ref> writes that safek derabbanan lkula only applies if he did something to permit the rabbinic prohibition. However, if he did nothing (dvar hamatiro) and there just is a safek, it is forbidden. However, Shaar Hamelech<ref>Mikvaot (10:6:1 and 7 at the end)</ref> argues. Here are his proofs: | ||
## Gemara Brachot 21a states that if Shema is only derabbanan and there's a safek if someone said Shema he doesn't need to repeat it. That indicates that safek derabbanan lkula is applied even though it is possible that no action was taken. However, it is possible to answer for Mishna Lmelech that a rabbinic mitzvah is more lenient and this type of safek is sufficient. | ## Gemara Brachot 21a states that if Shema is only derabbanan and there's a safek if someone said Shema he doesn't need to repeat it. That indicates that safek derabbanan lkula is applied even though it is possible that no action was taken. However, it is possible to answer for Mishna Lmelech that a rabbinic mitzvah is more lenient and this type of safek is sufficient. | ||
## Taz YD 69:24 writes that if someone doesn't remember if they salted a piece of meat before cooking it, it is permitted based on safek derabbanan lkula. Knesset Hagedola (Hagahot Bet Yosef 69:31) agrees. This implies that even though it is possible that no action was taken safek derabbanan lkula applies. | ## Taz YD 69:24 writes that if someone doesn't remember if they salted a piece of meat before cooking it, it is permitted based on safek derabbanan lkula. Knesset Hagedola (Hagahot Bet Yosef 69:31) agrees. This implies that even though it is possible that no action was taken safek derabbanan lkula applies. | ||
