16,374
edits
Klalei Halacha: Difference between revisions
From Halachipedia
→Safek Safeka with Chezkat Isur
| (One intermediate revision by the same user not shown) | |||
| Line 7: | Line 7: | ||
==Safek Safeka== | ==Safek Safeka== | ||
# Some say that safek safeka is only permitted after the fact.<Ref> The Reem on Smag Megillah writes that safek safeka is only permitted after the fact. See Rosh Bechorot 9a</ref> Many others disagree.<ref> Rav Ovadia in Chazon Ovadia 1:202 citing Perach Shoshan EH 3:2, Kol Eliyahu YD 2:2, Rosh A"Z 2:35</ref> | # Some say that safek safeka is only permitted after the fact.<Ref> The Reem on Smag Megillah writes that safek safeka is only permitted after the fact. See Rosh Bechorot 9a</ref> Many others disagree.<ref> Rav Ovadia in Chazon Ovadia 1:202 citing Perach Shoshan EH 3:2, Kol Eliyahu YD 2:2, Rosh A"Z 2:35</ref> | ||
==Safek Safeka MShem Echad== | |||
# A safek safeka that both sefakot rely on the same leniency isn't a safek safeka and is termed safek safeka mshem echad.<ref>Tosfot Ketubot 9a</ref> If one of the sefakot permit more than the other it is a valid safek safeka.<ref>Shach Klalei Safek Safeka n. 12. His proof is Tosfot Avoda Zara 38b with regards to Stam Kli Eino Ben Yomo.</ref> | |||
==Safek Derabbanan Lkula - Safek Eched Deoritta Safek Eched Derabbanan== | ==Safek Derabbanan Lkula - Safek Eched Deoritta Safek Eched Derabbanan== | ||
# Rashba Brachot 31a cites a dispute regarding something which is a Biblically forbidden but there’s a doubt if it is forbidden and additionally another reason why it might not be a Biblical prohibition but would be a rabbinic one. Do we say safek safeka in such a case? | # Rashba Brachot 31a cites a dispute regarding something which is a Biblically forbidden but there’s a doubt if it is forbidden and additionally another reason why it might not be a Biblical prohibition but would be a rabbinic one. Do we say safek safeka in such a case? | ||
| Line 29: | Line 31: | ||
==Safek Safeka with Chezkat Isur== | ==Safek Safeka with Chezkat Isur== | ||
# Some poskim disallow a safek safeka if it contradicts a chezkat isur,<ref>Shach 110:27, Taz 110:15</ref> while others permit it.<ref>Rama 110:9, Pri Chadash safek safeka 16. See Rashba teshuva 401</ref> Everyone agrees that a safek safek safeka works even if there's a chezkat isur.<ref>Shach 110:28</ref> | # Some poskim disallow a safek safeka if it contradicts a chezkat isur,<ref>Shach 110:27, Taz 110:15</ref> while others permit it.<ref>Rama 110:9, Pri Chadash safek safeka 16. See Rashba teshuva 401</ref> Everyone agrees that a safek safek safeka works even if there's a chezkat isur.<ref>Shach 110:28</ref> | ||
==Safek Safeka Lheter against a Safek Safeka Lisur== | |||
# If there are three safekot to permit something and only two to forbid it it is still considered a safek safeka and it is permitted.<ref>Rama 96:4 since it might not be cut with a non-kosher knife and the food might not be charif and the knife was eino ben yomo. The knife being eino ben yomo itself is a safek safeka. </ref> | |||
==Sources== | ==Sources== | ||
<references/> | <references/> | ||
