How Does a Posek Come up with His Pesak?: Difference between revisions
From Halachipedia
How Does a Posek Come up with His Pesak? (view source)
Revision as of 03:06, 12 August 2020
, 12 August 2020→Ashkenazic Style
(Created page with " ==Development of Pesak== right [https://www.yutorah.org/lectures/lecture.cfm/858663/rabbi-dr-j-david-bleich/klalei-horaah/ Rabbi Dr. J. Dav...") |
|||
| Line 40: | Line 40: | ||
#Igrot Moshe (v. 1 Introduction) boldly pronounced that once the truth is clarified according to the view of the rabbi, after he put a lot of effort to learn and analyze the halacha from the gemara and poskim, he should then pasken in accordance with his understanding. That is his obligation and even in this generation we can consider rabbis to be capable of giving a pesak that would arrive at the truth. | #Igrot Moshe (v. 1 Introduction) boldly pronounced that once the truth is clarified according to the view of the rabbi, after he put a lot of effort to learn and analyze the halacha from the gemara and poskim, he should then pasken in accordance with his understanding. That is his obligation and even in this generation we can consider rabbis to be capable of giving a pesak that would arrive at the truth. | ||
# Rav Schachter (Nefesh Harav p. 19 and p. 24) describes how one theme in brisker pesak is be concerned for all the opinions. Minhagim are part of the broader scope of torah, not just for how we follow them but also in how they are established. Any minhag which isn’t based on some version of the gemara or rishonim or has logical basis in halacha is a mistake. | # Rav Schachter (Nefesh Harav p. 19 and p. 24) describes how one theme in brisker pesak is be concerned for all the opinions. Minhagim are part of the broader scope of torah, not just for how we follow them but also in how they are established. Any minhag which isn’t based on some version of the gemara or rishonim or has logical basis in halacha is a mistake. | ||
[[Category:Rules for Determining Halacha]] | |||
