Hotzaah: Difference between revisions
From Halachipedia
→How to Measure 600,000
Line 64: | Line 64: | ||
##Some achronim argue that 600,000 includes people over any amount of time as long as theoretically for a special event or certain need 600,000 could come there in one day. According to this suggestion almost any public street is a reshut harabbim. | ##Some achronim argue that 600,000 includes people over any amount of time as long as theoretically for a special event or certain need 600,000 could come there in one day. According to this suggestion almost any public street is a reshut harabbim. | ||
#The Ramban suggests that even for Rashi a highway outside of a town is a reshut harabbim even if it lacks a population of 600,000. Rosh disagrees and holds that according to Rashi a reshut harabbim always depends on a population of 600,000. | #The Ramban suggests that even for Rashi a highway outside of a town is a reshut harabbim even if it lacks a population of 600,000. Rosh disagrees and holds that according to Rashi a reshut harabbim always depends on a population of 600,000. | ||
====Gaps more than 10 Amot==== | |||
#Mishkenot Yakov and Rav Aharon Kotler<Ref>Mishnat Rebbe Aharon 6</ref> hold that a gap more than 10 amot is deoritta. Chazon Ish<ref>OC siman 112:1-5</ref> argues that a gap more than 10 amot is only derabbanan. Bet Efraim holds that a gap of more than 10 amot is derabbanan if there are corners of at least an amah. | |||
===Applications to Specific City Eruvin=== | ===Applications to Specific City Eruvin=== |