Hotzaah: Difference between revisions
From Halachipedia
→Wire Goes into Pole
| Line 145: | Line 145: | ||
#Many poskim hold that the wire on top is acceptable even if it sways in the wind as long as it doesn't fall off the top of the side posts.<ref>Machasit Hashekel 362:18 writes that the wire on top can sway in the wind and although is part of a wall, doesn't have all the stringencies of a wall which cannot sway in the wind at all. Mishna Brurah agrees. Pri Megadim E"A 362:18 argues that every mechitza must be strong enough not to fall down in the wind but it doesn't matter if it would sway in the wind. For the wire on top he writes that it is kosher if it sways as well as it doesn't fall off the side posts. Chazon Ish agrees. However, unlike the above poskim, Mishna Brurah cites Mishkenot Yakov who holds that the wire is completely invalid if it sways in the wind at all. Kaf Hachaim 362:97 seems to be strict for Mishkenot Yakov.</ref> | #Many poskim hold that the wire on top is acceptable even if it sways in the wind as long as it doesn't fall off the top of the side posts.<ref>Machasit Hashekel 362:18 writes that the wire on top can sway in the wind and although is part of a wall, doesn't have all the stringencies of a wall which cannot sway in the wind at all. Mishna Brurah agrees. Pri Megadim E"A 362:18 argues that every mechitza must be strong enough not to fall down in the wind but it doesn't matter if it would sway in the wind. For the wire on top he writes that it is kosher if it sways as well as it doesn't fall off the side posts. Chazon Ish agrees. However, unlike the above poskim, Mishna Brurah cites Mishkenot Yakov who holds that the wire is completely invalid if it sways in the wind at all. Kaf Hachaim 362:97 seems to be strict for Mishkenot Yakov.</ref> | ||
===Skipping Poles=== | |||
#If two poles have a kosher side post and wire on top, some poskim allow skipping poles even though they have a wire going to the side of the post as long as it is in a straight line.<ref>Har Tzvi 2:18:12</ref> | |||
===Tzurat Hapetach Detached from a Wall=== | |||
#Some poskim hold that if a tzurat hapetach is detached from the wall more than 3 tefachim it is invalid. Others hold that it is invalid. A compromise view allows the tzurat hapetach if it is detached from one side but on the other side attached to a wall. Some are strict even in that case.<ref>[https://www.hebrewbooks.org/pdfpager.aspx?req=41113&st=&pgnum=2 Tikkun Eruvin p. 2] makes a compromise that it is valid if it is attached on one side, but invalid if it is detached on both sides. Har Tzvi 2:18:5 agrees.</ref> | |||
===Wire Goes into Pole=== | ===Wire Goes into Pole=== | ||
<center><gallery widths="175px" heights="200px" mode="nolines"> | <center><gallery widths="175px" heights="200px" mode="nolines"> | ||
