Having Kavana for Mitzvot: Difference between revisions

# Even though many Rishonim hold that Mitzvot don’t need Kavana (intent) to fulfill the mitzvah <ref> Rabbenu Chananel (Brachot 13a), Ravyah (Brachot 1:45), Or Zaruh (Shema 31), Rashbetz in name of Rav Shrira Goan and other Geonim, Rav Yitzchak Even Giyat in Meah Sharim (1 pg 36) in name of Rav Hai Goan, Rashbam (quoted by Talmedei Rabbenu Yonah 6a), Bal HaMoar (3rd Perek of [[Rosh Hashana]]), Itur (Shofar 2:1 pg 59b), Sefer Eshkol 3:6 pg 12, Sefer Hashlama (Brachot 13a), Sefer Meorot (Brachot 13a), Raah (Brachot 13a), Rashba (Brachot 13a; Sh”t Rashba 1:344), Ritva ([[Rosh Hashana]] 28b), and Meiri Brachot 13a-b, Sefer HaShulchan (Shema 2), Radvaz (4:1094 against what he writes in 6:2246) hold that Mitzvot don’t need Kavana to fulfill the mitzvah. Bal HaMoar, Talmedei Rabbenu Yonah, and Tur writes that even these opinions will hold that Lechatchila one should have Kavana. </ref> as long as one has Kavana to do the action of the Mitzvah and not to do it by accident one fulfilled one's obligation, nonetheless, <Ref> [[Rosh Hashana]] 32b and 33b say that a Metasek someone just involved in some action and by accident the mitzvah happens one doesn’t fulfill the obligation (even according to the opinions that hold Mitzvot don’t need Kavana). So rules S”A 589:10. </ref> Halacha follows the many Rishonim who hold that Mitzvot need Kavana to fulfill the Mitzvah. <Ref> Bahag (Brachot 2, 7) holds Mitzvot need Kavana. Rif ([[Rosh Hashana]] 7b) seems to agree as he rules like Rabbi Zeira that Shofar needs Kavana. Ravyah 2:533, Ramban (Milchamot [[Rosh Hashana]] 7b), Rosh ([[Rosh Hashana]] 3:11), Rabbenu Yerucham 6:2, Ran (Halachot [[Rosh Hashana]] 28b), and Meiri ([[Rosh Hashana]] 28b) explain the Rif in this way. Rashba ([[Rosh Hashana]] 28b), and Orchot Chaim (Shofar 8) explains Rif that one doesn’t need Kavana for Mitzvah just Kavana to listen to the Shofar. Tur 589 and Bet Yosef 589 understand the Rosh that Mitzvot need Kavana (See Sh”t Mishpat Tzedek 2:62 who explains that the Rosh holds only by Deoritta’s one needs Kavana). Rambam (Shofar 2:4) rules one needs Kavana but by Matzah 6:3 he rules one doesn’t need kavana. Ravad (Pesachim 10th Perek), Meiri and Ran ([[Rosh Hashana]] 28b) answer that Matzah doesn’t need Kavana because one gets benefit; thus, Rambam holds Mitzvot need Kavana. S”A 60:6, 589:8 rules that the halacha is Mitzvot need Kavana. </ref> If one has Kavana not to fulfill one’s obligation according to all opinions one doesn’t fulfill his obligation. <Ref> Bet Yosef 589 and S”A 6:4 rules that if one has Kavana not to be Yotze one doesn’t fulfill the obligation against one’s will based on many Rishonim unlike the Raah. See Sh”t Otzrot Yosef 3:9 </ref>