Guaranteed Low Prices and Interest: Difference between revisions
From Halachipedia
→Yesh Lo when the Item Naturally Matures
| Line 36: | Line 36: | ||
====Yesh Lo when the Item Naturally Matures==== | ====Yesh Lo when the Item Naturally Matures==== | ||
# If someone buys a certain amount of quantity of a commodity and it will mature naturally such as if someone bought gourds that were growing it is permitted for him to pay in advance even though when the gourds mature they would be more expensive.<ref>Bava Metsia 64a, Shulchan Aruch Y.D. 173:8</ref> The seller should then make sure to give him from the crop that he had when they arranged the sale.<ref>Hagahot Mordechai, Shach, and Taz. Chelkat Binyamin 173:112 writes that the Hagahot Mordechai doesn't mean that it is necessary to designate which very specific gourds he is going to sell, it is just necessary to say from his current crop he is going to sell and not going to buy others.</ref> As to the details of responsibility and insurance see footnote.<ref>Chelkat Binyamin 173:111 describes that most poskim hold that the mechanism here is a sale and as such it isn't the responsibility of the seller to buy others from the market if these ones spoil. If they were to do that it would be like poskin, stipulating to buy a future of a commodity, which is only permitted when the seller owns the product which isn't the case here. However, in the Biurim he writes that most rishonim indicate that even using the mechanism of pesika to have the seller responsible to ensure the commodity even if he has to buy more from the market. He says that one can rely on this lenient view.</ref> | # If someone buys a certain amount of quantity of a commodity and it will mature naturally such as if someone bought gourds that were growing it is permitted for him to pay in advance even though when the gourds mature they would be more expensive.<ref>Bava Metsia 64a, Shulchan Aruch Y.D. 173:8</ref> The seller should then make sure to give him from the crop that he had when they arranged the sale.<ref>Hagahot Mordechai, Shach, and Taz. Chelkat Binyamin 173:112 writes that the Hagahot Mordechai doesn't mean that it is necessary to designate which very specific gourds he is going to sell, it is just necessary to say from his current crop he is going to sell and not going to buy others.</ref> As to the details of responsibility and insurance see footnote.<ref>Chelkat Binyamin 173:111 describes that most poskim hold that the mechanism here is a sale and as such it isn't the responsibility of the seller to buy others from the market if these ones spoil. If they were to do that it would be like poskin, stipulating to buy a future of a commodity, which is only permitted when the seller owns the product which isn't the case here. However, in the Biurim he writes that most rishonim indicate that even using the mechanism of pesika to have the seller responsible to ensure the commodity even if he has to buy more from the market. He says that one can rely on this lenient view.</ref> | ||
# This leniency to advance cash to buy unripe produce only applies if it is normal for it to be sold in the market at that stage.<ref>Rama Y.D. 173:10 citing the Nemukei Yosef</ref> If it isn't normal for it to be sold that way then it is forbidden to pay less for buying it in advance. For example, one may not speculate and buy a vineyard of unripe grapes or grapevines for when they will ripen.<ref>Shulchan Aruch Y.D. 173:10-11, Taz 173:16</ref> | |||
====Buying All of the Producer's Product==== | |||
# Even if the producer doesn't have the product available it is permitted to make an advanced payment for all of the producer's product since there is risk involved and it is considered an investment as opposed to a loan.<ref>Bava Metsia 64a, Shulchan Aruch Y.D. 173:9. The example of the Gemara and Shulchan Aruch is a person selling all of the milk he will get from his cows, sheering from his sheep, or honey from his bees in one day. The Gemara explains that this isn't permitted based on the factor of yesh lo or the factor that naturally the product is produced like an immature gourd because there's nothing tangible from which the milk is created at the time of the sale which the buyer can acquire. Shach 173:21 and Taz 173:21 cite the gemara.</ref> | |||
# It is permitted to buy a calf and advance the cash and only collect the cow later if the buyer assumes responsibility if the cow dies or depreciates after he pays the money.<ref>Shulchan Aruch Y.D. 173:10</ref> | |||
==Future Contracts of Commodities== | ==Future Contracts of Commodities== | ||
