Erev Pesach That Falls out on Shabbat: Difference between revisions
From Halachipedia
Erev Pesach That Falls out on Shabbat (view source)
Revision as of 17:15, 10 June 2021
, 10 June 2021→Egg Matzah
| Line 51: | Line 51: | ||
* Hagahot Maimoniot 6:12:9 writes that Rabbenu Tam would eat egg matzah for seuda shelishit on Erev Pesach that fell out on Shabbat. This practice is also quoted in Smag Asin 40, Talmid Harashba 35b s.v. isa, Rashba (Teshuvot Hameyuchasot LRamban 210), Avudraham (Dinei Shlosh Seudot), Agur 712, Rosh Pesachim 10:1, Tashbetz 3:260, Orchot Chaim (Chametz 79). [In Hagahot Maimoniyot and Avudraham it seems that Rabbenu Tam would eat egg matzah during seuda shelishitbut aren't clear if that was the main food to fulfill his obligation. However, in the other rishonim's presentationo of Rabbenu Tam it is clear that he was using the egg matzah in order to fulfill his obligation of seuda shelishit.] Tosfot Pesachim 35b s.v. vmey, Tosfot Rashba 35b s.v. umey, Rosh 2:13, and Ritva 35a s.v. dardeki all quote that Rabbenu Tam ate egg matzah after midday on Erev Pesach but don't specify that he would use it for seuda shelishit. Rabbenu Peretz 36a s.v. isa quotes that Rashi would eat egg matzah on Erev Pesach (it is possible that it should be emended to say Rabbenu Tam.) | * Hagahot Maimoniot 6:12:9 writes that Rabbenu Tam would eat egg matzah for seuda shelishit on Erev Pesach that fell out on Shabbat. This practice is also quoted in Smag Asin 40, Talmid Harashba 35b s.v. isa, Rashba (Teshuvot Hameyuchasot LRamban 210), Avudraham (Dinei Shlosh Seudot), Agur 712, Rosh Pesachim 10:1, Tashbetz 3:260, Orchot Chaim (Chametz 79). [In Hagahot Maimoniyot and Avudraham it seems that Rabbenu Tam would eat egg matzah during seuda shelishitbut aren't clear if that was the main food to fulfill his obligation. However, in the other rishonim's presentationo of Rabbenu Tam it is clear that he was using the egg matzah in order to fulfill his obligation of seuda shelishit.] Tosfot Pesachim 35b s.v. vmey, Tosfot Rashba 35b s.v. umey, Rosh 2:13, and Ritva 35a s.v. dardeki all quote that Rabbenu Tam ate egg matzah after midday on Erev Pesach but don't specify that he would use it for seuda shelishit. Rabbenu Peretz 36a s.v. isa quotes that Rashi would eat egg matzah on Erev Pesach (it is possible that it should be emended to say Rabbenu Tam.) | ||
* Additionally, Rashba (Meyuchasot 210) writes that the Maharam's practice was also to eat egg matzah for seuda shelishit but with matzah made with fruit juice and not eggs like Rabbenu Tam. Orchot Chaim (Chametz 79) records this practice as well. | * Additionally, Rashba (Meyuchasot 210) writes that the Maharam's practice was also to eat egg matzah for seuda shelishit but with matzah made with fruit juice and not eggs like Rabbenu Tam. Orchot Chaim (Chametz 79) records this practice as well. | ||
* See also Nodeh Beyehuda 1:21. See Or Zaruah 2:256 s.v. lo yesev who implies that it is permitted to have egg matzah for seuda shelishit on Shabbat. Darkei Moshe Haaruch 444 cites the halacha in 471:2 and implies that it is only forbidden to eat egg matzah after the tenth hour and not after the fourth hour.</ref> | * See also Nodeh Beyehuda 1:21. See Or Zaruah 2:256 s.v. lo yesev who implies that it is permitted to have egg matzah for seuda shelishit on Shabbat. Darkei Moshe Haaruch 444 cites the halacha in 471:2 and implies that it is only forbidden to eat egg matzah after the tenth hour and not after the fourth hour. Minhagim of Rav Isaac Tirna (Erev Pesach) records the practice of eating egg matzah and the practice of eating fruit.</ref> | ||
===Cooked Matzah=== | ===Cooked Matzah=== | ||
