Anonymous

Corporations and Partnerships with Respect to Ribbit: Difference between revisions

From Halachipedia
Line 7: Line 7:
# According to those who are lenient, it is acceptable even if the partnership is unequal partnership and certain partners invested more than the others.<ref>Chelkat Binyamin 177:56 based on Chachmat Adam</ref>
# According to those who are lenient, it is acceptable even if the partnership is unequal partnership and certain partners invested more than the others.<ref>Chelkat Binyamin 177:56 based on Chachmat Adam</ref>
# According to those who are lenient to consider a partnership unlike an iska, some say that it is nonetheless forbidden for a working partner to accept more of the responsibility of losses and offer the other partners a greater share of the gains. Some are lenient on this.<ref>Chelkat Binyamin 177:57 writes that Chavot Daat forbids while the Shach 177:13 permits.</ref> Some say that it can be permitted if one gives an iska wage to the working partner, which could even be a [[dinar]], as described below ([[##Wages_for_an_Iska_Worker]]).<ref>Milveh Hashem 2:12:27 based on writes that if the worker partner gives the other investing partner a greater share of the profits then it is considered an iska that needs to be fixed by paying the partner for his work and even a dinar suffices. He writes that he is based on Shiurei Bracha YD 177:2 and Shulchano Shel Avraham 177:9. However, Chelkat Binyamin 177:57 argues that if it isn't equally apportioned it is forbidden according to the Chavot Daat and it can't be fixed by paying a dinar as it is completely ''karov lsachar vrachok mhefsed''.</ref>
# According to those who are lenient to consider a partnership unlike an iska, some say that it is nonetheless forbidden for a working partner to accept more of the responsibility of losses and offer the other partners a greater share of the gains. Some are lenient on this.<ref>Chelkat Binyamin 177:57 writes that Chavot Daat forbids while the Shach 177:13 permits.</ref> Some say that it can be permitted if one gives an iska wage to the working partner, which could even be a [[dinar]], as described below ([[##Wages_for_an_Iska_Worker]]).<ref>Milveh Hashem 2:12:27 based on writes that if the worker partner gives the other investing partner a greater share of the profits then it is considered an iska that needs to be fixed by paying the partner for his work and even a dinar suffices. He writes that he is based on Shiurei Bracha YD 177:2 and Shulchano Shel Avraham 177:9. However, Chelkat Binyamin 177:57 argues that if it isn't equally apportioned it is forbidden according to the Chavot Daat and it can't be fixed by paying a dinar as it is completely ''karov lsachar vrachok mhefsed''.</ref>
# According to those who are lenient to consider a partnership unlike an iska, some say that it is nonetheless forbidden for a working partner to offer another partner a fixed profit. Some are lenient on this.<ref>Chelkat Binyamin 177:58 writes that it is possibly worse than the dispute above and nonetheless the Torat Ribbit thinks it is comparable.</ref>
# According to those who are lenient to consider a partnership unlike an iska, some say that it is nonetheless forbidden for a working partner to offer another partner a fixed profit. Some are lenient on this.<ref>Chelkat Binyamin 177:58 writes that it is possibly worse than the dispute above and nonetheless the Torat Ribbit 27:4 thinks it is comparable.</ref>


==Corporations==
==Corporations==
Anonymous user