5
edits
Abortion: Difference between revisions
From Halachipedia
no edit summary
Jackbauer24 (talk | contribs) No edit summary |
Jackbauer24 (talk | contribs) No edit summary |
||
| Line 20: | Line 20: | ||
Most authorities permit In-vitro Fertilization.<ref>Yitzchak Bretowitz, “The Pre-Embryo in halacha”</ref> This is because it is not considered spilling the seed due to the fact that the long term goal of In- Vitro fertilization is to create life. | Most authorities permit In-vitro Fertilization.<ref>Yitzchak Bretowitz, “The Pre-Embryo in halacha”</ref> This is because it is not considered spilling the seed due to the fact that the long term goal of In- Vitro fertilization is to create life. | ||
#May a very early embryo be sacrificed for stem cells that could save lives or at least cure disease? | #May a very early embryo be sacrificed for stem cells that could save lives or at least cure disease? | ||
Most authorities would permit it for three reasons. 1. Even an implanted embryo before forty days of gestation is considered by some authorities not to be a life at all. <ref>Based on Yevamot 69b which refers to a pre 40 day fetus as “merely water” </ref> | Most authorities would permit it for three reasons. 1. Even an implanted embryo before forty days of gestation is considered by some authorities not to be a life at all. <ref>Based on Yevamot 69b which refers to a pre 40 day fetus as “merely water” </ref> 2. An unimplanted embryo may as well be considered not a life at all because it is outside of the womb.<ref>Yitzchak Bretowitz, “The Pre-Embryo in halacha”</ref> 3. Given that destroying a unimplanted pre forty day embryo is almost certainly not considered murder, the lifesaving potential of stem cell research can be considered the more important value. | ||
# May we fertilize ova specifically to create an embryo to be sacrificed for stem cells? | # May we fertilize ova specifically to create an embryo to be sacrificed for stem cells? | ||
Many authorities are uncomfortable with this procedure ethical even if it is unclear whether there is a specific halachic prohibition. <ref> Othodox Union (2001) Letter to President Bush Regarding Stem Cell Research </ref> | Many authorities are uncomfortable with this procedure ethical even if it is unclear whether there is a specific halachic prohibition. <ref> Othodox Union (2001) Letter to President Bush Regarding Stem Cell Research </ref> | ||
==Sources== | ==Sources== | ||
<references/> | <references/> | ||
