Minhag: Difference between revisions
From Halachipedia
→Communal Minhagim
Line 34: | Line 34: | ||
===Communal Minhagim=== | ===Communal Minhagim=== | ||
#A communal minhag that is meritorious can only be broken if the | #A communal minhag that is meritorious can only be broken if majority of the community does [[hatarat nedarim]]. An individual can't abrogated the minhag if he does a personal [[hatarat nedarim]].<ref>Pri Chadash (Dinei Minhagei Issur #5)</ref> | ||
#If a community has a practice, there is a dispute to what extent it applies to the next generation. One opinion holds that the minhag is not binding upon the next generation unless they have observed it one time.<ref>Zichron Yosef YD 14 cited by Pitchei Teshuva YD 214:5</ref> On the opposite end, some say the minhag is binding upon the children and it is impossible for them to do [[hatarat nedarim]] on that minhag because they weren't the ones who instituted it.<ref>Maharshdam YD 40, Maharik 144</ref> In the middle are those who say that the minhag is binding upon the next generation but they can do [[hatarat nedarim]] just like the previous generation could.<ref>Pri Chadash (Dinei Minhagei Issur #8)</ref> | #If a community has a practice, there is a dispute to what extent it applies to the next generation. One opinion holds that the minhag is not binding upon the next generation unless they have observed it one time.<ref>Zichron Yosef YD 14 cited by Pitchei Teshuva YD 214:5</ref> On the opposite end, some say the minhag is binding upon the children and it is impossible for them to do [[hatarat nedarim]] on that minhag because they weren't the ones who instituted it.<ref>Maharshdam YD 40, Maharik 144</ref> In the middle are those who say that the minhag is binding upon the next generation but they can do [[hatarat nedarim]] just like the previous generation could.<ref>Pri Chadash (Dinei Minhagei Issur #8)</ref> | ||
===Universal Minhagim=== | ===Universal Minhagim=== | ||
#A minhag that was accepted by all Jews can't be broken by a [[hatarat nedarim]].<ref>Pri Chadash (Dinei Minhagei Issur #6) citing Sh"t Maharshal 7</ref> | #A minhag that was accepted by all Jews can't be broken by a [[hatarat nedarim]].<ref>Pri Chadash (Dinei Minhagei Issur #6) citing Sh"t Maharshal 7</ref> |