Communal Responsibility

From Halachipedia

Halacha places high importance on a community's responsibility to one another. A community is halachically obligated to fund communal needs. These needs include security needs; a community is required to build a wall and gates. These needs also include religous needs; a community is required to build a synagogue and ensure that is well stocked with a sefer Torah and seforim.

Rationales behind Communal Responsibility

Extent of Communal Responsibility

A big component of the halachic discussion around how far communal responsibility extends comes from a crucial Tshuva of the Maharik. This Tshuva of the Maharik is quoted by the Rema and by many generations of Achronim, thereby making it a really focal point for the discussion of communal responsibility.The Maharik argued that in a case where there is a risk to the Jewish people of a region, all Jewish communities are required to pitch in. We will structure the article around the Tshuva and the response of other poskim in order to examine how poskim viewed the question.

Background of Maharik's Ruling

Sketch of Shul of Regensburg in 1519

In the late 1470s- a major blood libel broke out in Regensburg. The city of Regensburg imprisoned seventeen leading members of the Jewish community. After repeated negotiations the city of Regensburg agreed to release the imprisoned Jews in exchange for the payment of an immense sum; 23,000 florins. The Jewish community of Regensburg asked all the other communities of Germany to assist in paying the expense. The Rabbonim of Germany in turn asked the Maharik, Rav Yosef Colon (1420-1480), over whether they were obligated to pay. It is to these rabbonim that the Maharik directed his ruling.

Ruling of the Maharik

The Maharik noted that were the blood libel not to be stopped, it would lead to the persecution of other Jewish communities

Explanations of the Maharik's Ruling

Opponents of the Maharik's Ruling