Tashlumin: Difference between revisions

From Halachipedia
m (Text replace - "mussaf" to "Mussaf")
m (Text replace - " Rosh Chodesh" to " Rosh Chodesh")
Line 27: Line 27:
==If one forgot to say Mincha on Friday afternoon==
==If one forgot to say Mincha on Friday afternoon==
# If one forgot to say Mincha on Friday one should say Arvit on Friday night, two [[Shemoneh Esrei]]s of [[Shabbat]], the first one for Arvit and the second as a makeup for Mincha (Tashlumin). <Ref>S”A 108:9 </ref>
# If one forgot to say Mincha on Friday one should say Arvit on Friday night, two [[Shemoneh Esrei]]s of [[Shabbat]], the first one for Arvit and the second as a makeup for Mincha (Tashlumin). <Ref>S”A 108:9 </ref>
==If one forgot to say Mincha before Rosh Chodesh==
==If one forgot to say Mincha before [[Rosh Chodesh]]==
# If one forgot to say Mincha before [[Rosh Chodesh]] one should say Arvit on Rosh Chodesh, two [[Shemoneh Esrei]]s with [[Yaaleh VeYavo]], the first one for Arvit and the second as a makeup for Mincha (Tashlumin). <Ref>Bet Yosef 422:2 quotes the Kol Bo who says that one only needs to say [[Yaaleh VeYavo]] in the first [[Shemoneh Esrei]]. The Levush 108:9, Olot Tamid 108:12, and the Bet Yosef (as it seems from the Bet Yosef there) agree with the Kol Bo. However, the Darkei Moshe 422:2 argues that one needs to say [[Yaaleh VeYavo]] Magan Avraham (108:7, 10, and 12), Kitzur S”A 21:6, Chaye Adam, and other Achronim including Mishna Brurah 108:26 hold that one should say [[Yaaleh VeYavo]] in both [[Shemoneh Esrei]]s. Halacha Brurah 108:27 (quotingn his father Rav Ovadyah) also agrees with Mishna Brurah. </ref>
# If one forgot to say Mincha before [[Rosh Chodesh]] one should say Arvit on [[Rosh Chodesh]], two [[Shemoneh Esrei]]s with [[Yaaleh VeYavo]], the first one for Arvit and the second as a makeup for Mincha (Tashlumin). <Ref>Bet Yosef 422:2 quotes the Kol Bo who says that one only needs to say [[Yaaleh VeYavo]] in the first [[Shemoneh Esrei]]. The Levush 108:9, Olot Tamid 108:12, and the Bet Yosef (as it seems from the Bet Yosef there) agree with the Kol Bo. However, the Darkei Moshe 422:2 argues that one needs to say [[Yaaleh VeYavo]] Magan Avraham (108:7, 10, and 12), Kitzur S”A 21:6, Chaye Adam, and other Achronim including Mishna Brurah 108:26 hold that one should say [[Yaaleh VeYavo]] in both [[Shemoneh Esrei]]s. Halacha Brurah 108:27 (quotingn his father Rav Ovadyah) also agrees with Mishna Brurah. </ref>
# If one forgot to say Mincha before [[Rosh Chodesh]] one should say Arvit on Rosh Chodesh, two [[Shemoneh Esrei]]s with [[Yaaleh VeYavo]]. However, if one did said [[Yaaleh VeYavo]] in the second but not the first, one has not fulfilled one’s obligation. <ref> The Rama 108:9 writes that if one said [[Yaaleh VeYavo]] in the second but not first [[Shemoneh Esrei]] one has no fulfilled one’s obligation of Tashlumin and must repeat it because one has revealed that it was one’s intent to put the Tashlumin first. The Rama is based on a comparison to the law of the Gemara Brachot 26b that if one forgot [[Mincha]] on [[Shabbat]] one should say Arvit twice on Motzei [[Shabbat]] and if one said [[Havdalah]]  in the second and not the first one has not fulfilled one’s obligation (because one has revealed one’s intent was to put the Tashlumin [[Shemoneh Esrei]] first). This is also found in the Kol Bo (siman 11, quoted in Bet Yosef 422:2) and is accepted by many Achronim including Mishna Brurah 108:27. </ref> However, according to Sephardim some say that one should make a stipulation that if one isn’t obligated that one prays voluntarily. <Ref>The Yeshuot Yacov 108:11 argues that one has fulfilled one’s obligation because one only said [[Yaaleh VeYavo]] in the second [[Shemoneh Esrei]] because initially it is the proper thing to say [[Yaaleh VeYavo]] in the second [[Shemoneh Esrei]]. According to this one could answer (Halacha Brurah, Birur Halacha 108:22) that the Kol Bo only said that one should repeat Tashlumin since he holds that one should only say [[Yaaleh VeYavo]] in the first [[Shemoneh Esrei]]. Therefore, the Halacha Brurah 108:27 writes that one should repeat one’s [[Shemoneh Esrei]] on condition that if one isn’t obligated that it should be a voluntary prayer. </ref>
# If one forgot to say Mincha before [[Rosh Chodesh]] one should say Arvit on [[Rosh Chodesh]], two [[Shemoneh Esrei]]s with [[Yaaleh VeYavo]]. However, if one did said [[Yaaleh VeYavo]] in the second but not the first, one has not fulfilled one’s obligation. <ref> The Rama 108:9 writes that if one said [[Yaaleh VeYavo]] in the second but not first [[Shemoneh Esrei]] one has no fulfilled one’s obligation of Tashlumin and must repeat it because one has revealed that it was one’s intent to put the Tashlumin first. The Rama is based on a comparison to the law of the Gemara Brachot 26b that if one forgot [[Mincha]] on [[Shabbat]] one should say Arvit twice on Motzei [[Shabbat]] and if one said [[Havdalah]]  in the second and not the first one has not fulfilled one’s obligation (because one has revealed one’s intent was to put the Tashlumin [[Shemoneh Esrei]] first). This is also found in the Kol Bo (siman 11, quoted in Bet Yosef 422:2) and is accepted by many Achronim including Mishna Brurah 108:27. </ref> However, according to Sephardim some say that one should make a stipulation that if one isn’t obligated that one prays voluntarily. <Ref>The Yeshuot Yacov 108:11 argues that one has fulfilled one’s obligation because one only said [[Yaaleh VeYavo]] in the second [[Shemoneh Esrei]] because initially it is the proper thing to say [[Yaaleh VeYavo]] in the second [[Shemoneh Esrei]]. According to this one could answer (Halacha Brurah, Birur Halacha 108:22) that the Kol Bo only said that one should repeat Tashlumin since he holds that one should only say [[Yaaleh VeYavo]] in the first [[Shemoneh Esrei]]. Therefore, the Halacha Brurah 108:27 writes that one should repeat one’s [[Shemoneh Esrei]] on condition that if one isn’t obligated that it should be a voluntary prayer. </ref>
==Mourner==
==Mourner==
# A person who became a mourner after the time for Shacharit or Mincha began and didn’t yet pray, some say that one is obligated to make Tashlumin (after the burial), and some say that one isn't obligated. <ref> Mishna Brurah 71, Magan Giborim and Derech HaChaim hold that a person is chayav, while the Yad Efrayim (Aninut 29), Birkei Yosef 341:17, Chachmat Shlomo  71, and Sh”t Shevet HaLevi 6:11 hold that one is exempt from Tashlumin. </ref>
# A person who became a mourner after the time for Shacharit or Mincha began and didn’t yet pray, some say that one is obligated to make Tashlumin (after the burial), and some say that one isn't obligated. <ref> Mishna Brurah 71, Magan Giborim and Derech HaChaim hold that a person is chayav, while the Yad Efrayim (Aninut 29), Birkei Yosef 341:17, Chachmat Shlomo  71, and Sh”t Shevet HaLevi 6:11 hold that one is exempt from Tashlumin. </ref>

Revision as of 15:33, 26 April 2013

General rules

  1. If one forgot to say Shacharit one should say Mincha twice, the first for Mincha and the second as a makeup (Tashlumin) of Shacharit. [1]
  2. If one forgot to say Mincha one should say Arvit twice, the first for Arvit, the second as a makeup (Tashlumin) of Mincha. [2]
  3. If one forgot to say Arvit one should say Shacharit twice, the first for Shacharit, the second as a makeup (Tashlumin) of Arvit. [3]

Procedure of Tashlumin

  1. In general, one shouldn't make any interruption in between the original Shemonah Esrei and the Tashlumin [4]besides for certain prayers which are mentioned in the following halachot:
  2. If one needs to say Tashlumin for Arvit one should say Shacharit Shemona Esrei, Tachanun, and Ashrei and then the Tashlumin Shemona Esrei.[5]
  3. If one needs to say Tashlumin for Shacharit one should say Mincha Shemona Esrei say Ashrei and then say the Tashlumin Shemona Esreh.[6]
  4. If one needs to say Tashlumin for Mincha, according to some poskim, one should say Arvit Shemona Esreh and Ashrei and then the Tashlumin, while others say that one should just say Avrit Shemona Esreh and then Tashlumin after waiting the time it takes to walk 4 amot. [7]

Having intent to specify the second as Tashlumin

  1. Preferably, one should have intent to specify the first one to be for the current Tefillah and the second as the makeup (Tashlumin) of the previous Tefillah.
  2. If one had no specific intent when praying the two Shemoneh Esreis one fulfills one’s obligation. [8]
  3. If one mistakenly had intent that the first one would be Tashlumin and the second for current Tefillah one didn’t fulfill one’s obligation with the Tashlumin. However, some say that one should stipulate that if one isn’t obligated that one is praying a voluntary prayer. [9]

Tashlumin for Mussaf

  1. There is no makeup (Tashlumin) if one missed saying Mussaf. [10]
  2. Some say that there's no Tashlumin if one missed Neilah of Yom Kippur, while others disagree. [11]

Women

  1. A woman who usually prays three times a day and misses a prayer unintentionally the same halacha of Tashlumin applies and she should pray the next Tefillah twice, the second as the makeup (Tashlumin). [12]

Using Chazarat HaShatz

  1. If the Shaliach Tzibbur has to pray a second prayer as Tashlumin, he should intend that the Chazarat HaShatz should counts as Tashlumin. [13]
  2. According to Ashkenazim, an individual who has to pray Tashlumin listening to Chazarat HaShatz will not fulfill one’s obligation rather one must pray oneself. However, after the fact one does fulfill one’s obligation for Tashlumin of Arvit/Mariv but not for any other prayer. [14]
  3. According to Sephardim, an individual who has to pray Tashlumin has the option to listen intently (to every word) to Chazarat HaShatz with intent to fulfill his obligation of Tashlumin, however, it’s preferable to pray Tashlumin (a second prayer) oneself. [15]
    1. If one does listen to the Chazarat HaShatz to fulfill one’s obligation one should answer Kedusha and Amen but not answer Baruch Hu UBaruch Shemo. [16]

If one forgot to say Mincha on Friday afternoon

  1. If one forgot to say Mincha on Friday one should say Arvit on Friday night, two Shemoneh Esreis of Shabbat, the first one for Arvit and the second as a makeup for Mincha (Tashlumin). [17]

If one forgot to say Mincha before Rosh Chodesh

  1. If one forgot to say Mincha before Rosh Chodesh one should say Arvit on Rosh Chodesh, two Shemoneh Esreis with Yaaleh VeYavo, the first one for Arvit and the second as a makeup for Mincha (Tashlumin). [18]
  2. If one forgot to say Mincha before Rosh Chodesh one should say Arvit on Rosh Chodesh, two Shemoneh Esreis with Yaaleh VeYavo. However, if one did said Yaaleh VeYavo in the second but not the first, one has not fulfilled one’s obligation. [19] However, according to Sephardim some say that one should make a stipulation that if one isn’t obligated that one prays voluntarily. [20]

Mourner

  1. A person who became a mourner after the time for Shacharit or Mincha began and didn’t yet pray, some say that one is obligated to make Tashlumin (after the burial), and some say that one isn't obligated. [21]

Sources

  1. ↑ Rabbi Yochanan in Gemara Brachot 26a establishes that one has the ability to makeup a prayer that one missed. This halacha is quoted and discussed in detail in the Tur and S”A 108:1. The Halacha Brurah (Shaar HaTzion 108:1) writes that the rabbis instituted Tashlumin as an obligation and it’s not just voluntary.
  2. ↑ S”A 108:2 based on the Gemara Brachot 26a
  3. ↑ S”A 108:2 based on the Gemara Brachot 26a
  4. ↑ Mishna Brurah 108:11 writes that preferably one shouldn't make any interruption even to learn in between the original Shemona Esrei and the Tashlumin.
  5. ↑ S"A 108:2
  6. ↑ Mishna Brurah 108:13
  7. ↑ Rama 108:2 writes that if one say saying Tashlumin for mincha one should say Ashrei between Arvit and the Tashlumin. However, Mishna Brurah 108:14 quotes the achronim in the name of the mekubalim that one shouldn't say Ashrei at Arvit. Kitzur S"A 21:1 just writes that at Arvit one should only wait the time it takes to walk 4 amot and not say Ashrei. Nonetheless, S"A 105:1 writes that one must wait at least the time it takes to walk 4 amot between two Shemona Esrei's. Mishna Brurah 105:1 explains that even if one doesn't say Ashrei at Arvit one must still make the time for 4 amot between the Shemona Esrei and Tashlumin.
  8. ↑ Biur Halacha 108:1 D”H VeIm Hiyfech, Kaf HaChaim 108:3, Yalkut Yosef (Kitzur S”A 108:1)
  9. ↑
    • The halacha that the first one is supposed to be Mincha and the second Tashlumin for Shacharit is based on the Briatta on the top of Brachot 26b which says that if one forgot to say Mincha of Shabbat one should say Arvit on Motzei Shabbat twice the first one with Havdalah (Atta Chonatanu) and the second without Havdalah and if one switched the order one has not fulfilled one’s obligation. The implication is that whenever one makes Tashlumin one should put the Shemoneh Esrei one is obligated in presently first and then the Tashlumin and if one did the opposite one hasn’t fulfilled one’s obligation. This is the ruling of the Tur, Darkei Moshe, and S”A 108:1. Many Achronim agree with this opinion including Eliyah Rabba 108:1, Ben Ish Chai (Mishpatim #9), and Nahar Shalom 108:2.
    • However, the Magan Avraham 108:2 questions S”A saying that explicit intent isn’t indicative but rather the only time when one doesn’t fulfill one’s obligation is when one adds a prayer into one of the Shemoneh Esreis which clearly reveals that one meant the Tashlumin to be first. The Taz 108:2, Chaye 27:4, Chida in Kesher Gudal 22:11 agree with the Magan Avraham.
    • In conclusion, the S”A HaRav 108:1 and Pri Megadim (A”A 108:2) write that one should be concerned for the opinion of the Magan Avraham and if one makes a mistake and has intent that the first one should be the Tashlumin then one should pray again voluntarily. However, the Biur Halacha 108:1 D”H VeIm Hiyfech writes that the halacha follows S”A. The Yalkut Yosef (108:1, Tefillah pg 566, Sherit Yosef vol 3 pg 75) writes that the primary halacha follows the S”A however it’s preferable to stipulate that if one isn’t obligated that one is praying a voluntary prayer.
  10. ↑ Tosfot (Brachot 26a D”H Iybah) writes that there’s no tashlumin for Mussaf because you can’t say the (pesukim or inyan of) Korbanot at night and Mussaf was instituted as a remembrance of Korbanot and not a request of mercy. Rabbenu Yonah 18a D”G Taah(2), and Rosh 4:1 agree. This is the ruling of Tur and S”A 108:6. Kitzur S"A 21:8 concurs.
  11. ↑ Chazon Ovadya (Yamim Noraim, Hilchot Neilah) writes that there's no Tashlumin for Neilah, while the Or Letzion argues that there is Tashlumin for Neilah.
  12. ↑ Halacha Brurah 108:3
  13. ↑ Magan Avraham 108:1, Mishna Brurah 108:4, Halacha Brurah 108:4
  14. ↑ Mishna Brurah 108:5
  15. ↑ Halacha Brurah 108:5
  16. ↑ Halacha Brurah 108:5
  17. ↑ S”A 108:9
  18. ↑ Bet Yosef 422:2 quotes the Kol Bo who says that one only needs to say Yaaleh VeYavo in the first Shemoneh Esrei. The Levush 108:9, Olot Tamid 108:12, and the Bet Yosef (as it seems from the Bet Yosef there) agree with the Kol Bo. However, the Darkei Moshe 422:2 argues that one needs to say Yaaleh VeYavo Magan Avraham (108:7, 10, and 12), Kitzur S”A 21:6, Chaye Adam, and other Achronim including Mishna Brurah 108:26 hold that one should say Yaaleh VeYavo in both Shemoneh Esreis. Halacha Brurah 108:27 (quotingn his father Rav Ovadyah) also agrees with Mishna Brurah.
  19. ↑ The Rama 108:9 writes that if one said Yaaleh VeYavo in the second but not first Shemoneh Esrei one has no fulfilled one’s obligation of Tashlumin and must repeat it because one has revealed that it was one’s intent to put the Tashlumin first. The Rama is based on a comparison to the law of the Gemara Brachot 26b that if one forgot Mincha on Shabbat one should say Arvit twice on Motzei Shabbat and if one said Havdalah in the second and not the first one has not fulfilled one’s obligation (because one has revealed one’s intent was to put the Tashlumin Shemoneh Esrei first). This is also found in the Kol Bo (siman 11, quoted in Bet Yosef 422:2) and is accepted by many Achronim including Mishna Brurah 108:27.
  20. ↑ The Yeshuot Yacov 108:11 argues that one has fulfilled one’s obligation because one only said Yaaleh VeYavo in the second Shemoneh Esrei because initially it is the proper thing to say Yaaleh VeYavo in the second Shemoneh Esrei. According to this one could answer (Halacha Brurah, Birur Halacha 108:22) that the Kol Bo only said that one should repeat Tashlumin since he holds that one should only say Yaaleh VeYavo in the first Shemoneh Esrei. Therefore, the Halacha Brurah 108:27 writes that one should repeat one’s Shemoneh Esrei on condition that if one isn’t obligated that it should be a voluntary prayer.
  21. ↑ Mishna Brurah 71, Magan Giborim and Derech HaChaim hold that a person is chayav, while the Yad Efrayim (Aninut 29), Birkei Yosef 341:17, Chachmat Shlomo 71, and Sh”t Shevet HaLevi 6:11 hold that one is exempt from Tashlumin.
Retrieved from "http://localhost:80/index.php?title=Tashlumin&oldid=9247"