Brachot on a Nice Smell: Difference between revisions
From Halachipedia
m (Text replace - " Sukkot" to " Sukkot") |
No edit summary |
||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
Just like it is forbidden to benefit from a food without making a Bracha Rishona, it is also forbidden to benefit from a nice smell before making a bracha.<ref>Kitzur S"A 58:1</ref> | Just like it is forbidden to benefit from a food without making a Bracha Rishona, it is also forbidden to benefit from a nice smell before making a bracha.<ref>Kitzur S"A 58:1</ref> | ||
==Havdalah== | ==Havdalah== | ||
# The Ashkenaz minhag is to make Boreh | # The Ashkenaz minhag is to make Boreh Minei Besamim (בורא מיני בשמים) which is the general Bracha for nice smells at Havdalavah no matter what’s being used for besamim. However, according to Sephardim, one should make the appropriate Bracha for that besamim. <Ref>Mishna Brurah 297:1, Vezot HaBracha (pg 181, chapter 19) </ref> | ||
# During the rest of the week, there’s no argument that there’s a distinction between the following categories: | # During the rest of the week, there’s no argument that there’s a distinction between the following categories: | ||
==Boreh Atzei Besamim== | ==Boreh Atzei Besamim== | ||
| Line 12: | Line 12: | ||
# For edible fruits that give off a strong smell (from the fruit and not from the peel) the Bracha required is HaNoten Rayach Tov BaPerot. The major limitation of this category is that one should only make the Bracha for a strong smell and only if the fruit is taken to smell and not to eat. <Ref>Vezot HaBracha (pg 175, chapter 19) </ref> | # For edible fruits that give off a strong smell (from the fruit and not from the peel) the Bracha required is HaNoten Rayach Tov BaPerot. The major limitation of this category is that one should only make the Bracha for a strong smell and only if the fruit is taken to smell and not to eat. <Ref>Vezot HaBracha (pg 175, chapter 19) </ref> | ||
# Examples: Etrog (not on [[Sukkot]]), quince, apple, melon <Ref>Vezot HaBracha (pg 175, chapter 19) </ref> | # Examples: Etrog (not on [[Sukkot]]), quince, apple, melon <Ref>Vezot HaBracha (pg 175, chapter 19) </ref> | ||
==Boreh | ==Boreh Minei Besamim== | ||
# The general Bracha for nice smells is Boreh | # The general Bracha for nice smells is Boreh Minei Besamim and is made for non-plant or fruit products, or for items for which there’s an unresolved dispute in the poskim. <ref>Vezot HaBracha (pg 175-7, chapter 19) </ref> | ||
# Examples: cinnamon, cloves (common for [[Havdalah]] ), lemon, hot ground coffee beans (taken to smell), mixture of tree and shrub products. <ref>Vezot HaBracha (pg 397, Luach Brachot) </ref> | # Examples: cinnamon, cloves (common for [[Havdalah]] ), lemon, hot ground coffee beans (taken to smell), mixture of tree and shrub products. <ref>Vezot HaBracha (pg 397, Luach Brachot) </ref> | ||
# For synthetic smells, as is common in cheap perfumes, some say that the Bracha is Boreh | # For synthetic smells, as is common in cheap perfumes, some say that the Bracha is Boreh Minei Besamim and some say that there’s no Bracha on such a smell. <Ref> Vezot HaBracha (pg 182, chapter 19) quotes a dispute between Rav Pinchas Sheinburg who says that synthetic products have a Bracha, and Rav Shlomo Zalman Auerbach who holds that no Bracha is made. </ref> | ||
==After the fact== | ==After the fact== | ||
| Line 21: | Line 21: | ||
# The Bracha of Atzi doesn’t cover the products that require Isbei and the Bracha of Isbei doesn't cover products that require Atzi. <Ref>Kitzur S"A 58:7, Mishna Brurah 216:39, Vezot HaBracha (pg 176, chapter 19) </ref> | # The Bracha of Atzi doesn’t cover the products that require Isbei and the Bracha of Isbei doesn't cover products that require Atzi. <Ref>Kitzur S"A 58:7, Mishna Brurah 216:39, Vezot HaBracha (pg 176, chapter 19) </ref> | ||
==If one’s in doubt== | ==If one’s in doubt== | ||
# If you have a plant which has a nice smell but you personally are in doubt as to whether the Bracha is Atzei or Isbei, if it’s easy to find out the correct Bracha, one should do so, otherwise, one may make Boreh | # If you have a plant which has a nice smell but you personally are in doubt as to whether the Bracha is Atzei or Isbei, if it’s easy to find out the correct Bracha, one should do so, otherwise, one may make Boreh Minei Besamim. (This is different than foods where there’s an obligation to figure out the appropriate halacha instead of making Shehakol.) <ref>Kitzur S"A 58:7, Vezot HaBracha (pg 176, chapter 19) </ref> | ||
# If one is unsure whether a product has a nice or strong smell, one may smell it to check, make the Bracha, and then make the Bracha. <Ref>Vezot HaBracha (pg 180, chapter 19), [https://docs.google.com/viewer?url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.thehalacha.com%2Fattach%2FVolume4%2FIssue11.pdf Halachically Speaking] quoting Ben Ish Chai (VeEtchanan#2). </ref> | # If one is unsure whether a product has a nice or strong smell, one may smell it to check, make the Bracha, and then make the Bracha. <Ref>Vezot HaBracha (pg 180, chapter 19), [https://docs.google.com/viewer?url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.thehalacha.com%2Fattach%2FVolume4%2FIssue11.pdf Halachically Speaking] quoting Ben Ish Chai (VeEtchanan#2). </ref> | ||
==No Bracha== | ==No Bracha== | ||
| Line 30: | Line 30: | ||
==List of Brachot== | ==List of Brachot== | ||
<table width="700" border="1" cellpadding="1" cellspacing="1" bordercolor="#000000" bgcolor="#FFFFFF"><tr> <td><span class="style5"> Item </span></td> <td><span class="style5"> Ashkenazim (Vezot HaBracha, Luach Brachot) </span></td> <td><span class="style5"> Sephardim (Birkat Hashem vol 3) </span></td> | <table width="700" border="1" cellpadding="1" cellspacing="1" bordercolor="#000000" bgcolor="#FFFFFF"><tr> <td><span class="style5"> Item </span></td> <td><span class="style5"> Ashkenazim (Vezot HaBracha, Luach Brachot) </span></td> <td><span class="style5"> Sephardim (Birkat Hashem vol 3) </span></td> | ||
</tr><tr> <td> Air freshener (if taken to smell) </td> <td> No Bracha </td> <td> | </tr><tr> <td> Air freshener (if taken to smell) </td> <td> No Bracha </td> <td> Minei Besamim </td></tr><tr> | ||
</tr><tr> <td> Black pepper </td> <td> Questionable <ref> The Mishna Brurah 297:1 rules that since there is a dispute among the poskim (whether one should make any bracha on it) one shouldn't make a bracha on it. The Vezot HaBracha (pg 179) agrees and adds that due to this dispute one should refrain from smelling it. </ref></td> <td> | </tr><tr> <td> Black pepper </td> <td> Questionable <ref> The Mishna Brurah 297:1 rules that since there is a dispute among the poskim (whether one should make any bracha on it) one shouldn't make a bracha on it. The Vezot HaBracha (pg 179) agrees and adds that due to this dispute one should refrain from smelling it. </ref></td> <td> Minei Besamim <ref> Kaf HaChaim 297:5, Rav Moshe HaLevi (Menuchat Ahava (vol 1 9:24) and Birkat Hashem (vol 3, 12:17), Ish Matzliach (commentary on Mishna Brurah 297:1) </ref></td></tr><tr> | ||
</tr><tr> <td> Cinnamon </td> <td> | </tr><tr> <td> Cinnamon </td> <td> Minei Besamim </td> <td> Minei Besamim </td></tr><tr> | ||
</tr><tr> <td> Cloves </td> <td> | </tr><tr> <td> Cloves </td> <td> Minei Besamim </td> <td> Atzei Besamim </td></tr><tr> | ||
</tr><tr> <td> Daffodil </td> <td> Isbei Besamim </td> <td> | </tr><tr> <td> Daffodil </td> <td> Isbei Besamim </td> <td> Minei Besamim </td></tr><tr> | ||
</tr><tr> <td> Deodorant </td> <td> Dispute </td> <td> | </tr><tr> <td> Deodorant </td> <td> Dispute </td> <td> Minei Besamim </td></tr><tr> | ||
</tr><tr> <td> Etrog </td> <td> HaNoten Rayach Tov BeParot </td> <td> HaNoten Rayach Tov BeParot </td></tr><tr> | </tr><tr> <td> Etrog </td> <td> HaNoten Rayach Tov BeParot </td> <td> HaNoten Rayach Tov BeParot </td></tr><tr> | ||
</tr><tr> <td> Ground coffee beans </td> <td> | </tr><tr> <td> Ground coffee beans </td> <td> Minei Besamim </td> <td> No Bracha </td></tr><tr> | ||
</tr><tr> <td> Hadas (myrtle) </td> <td> Atzei Besamim </td> <td> Atzei Besamim </td></tr><tr> | </tr><tr> <td> Hadas (myrtle) </td> <td> Atzei Besamim </td> <td> Atzei Besamim </td></tr><tr> | ||
</tr><tr> <td> Honeysuckle </td> <td> Atzei Besamim </td> <td> - </td></tr><tr> | </tr><tr> <td> Honeysuckle </td> <td> Atzei Besamim </td> <td> - </td></tr><tr> | ||
</tr><tr> <td> Hyacinth </td> <td> Isbei Besamim </td> <td> - </td></tr><tr> | </tr><tr> <td> Hyacinth </td> <td> Isbei Besamim </td> <td> - </td></tr><tr> | ||
</tr><tr> <td> Jasmine </td> <td> Atzei Besamim </td> <td> - </td></tr><tr> | </tr><tr> <td> Jasmine </td> <td> Atzei Besamim </td> <td> - </td></tr><tr> | ||
</tr><tr> <td> Lemon </td> <td> | </tr><tr> <td> Lemon </td> <td> Minei Besamim </td> <td> Minei Besamim </td></tr><tr> | ||
</tr><tr> <td> Melon </td> <td> HaNoten Rayach Tov BeParot </td> <td> - </td></tr><tr> | </tr><tr> <td> Melon </td> <td> HaNoten Rayach Tov BeParot </td> <td> - </td></tr><tr> | ||
</tr><tr> <td> Mint </td> <td> Isbei Besamim </td> <td> Isbei Besamim </td></tr><tr> | </tr><tr> <td> Mint </td> <td> Isbei Besamim </td> <td> Isbei Besamim </td></tr><tr> | ||
</tr><tr> <td> Orange </td> <td> - </td> <td> | </tr><tr> <td> Orange </td> <td> - </td> <td> Minei Besamim </td></tr><tr> | ||
</tr><tr> <td> Quince </td> <td> HaNoten Rayach Tov BeParot </td> <td> - </td></tr><tr> | </tr><tr> <td> Quince </td> <td> HaNoten Rayach Tov BeParot </td> <td> - </td></tr><tr> | ||
</tr><tr> <td> Rose </td> <td> Atzei Besamim </td> <td> Atzei Besamim </td></tr><tr> | </tr><tr> <td> Rose </td> <td> Atzei Besamim </td> <td> Atzei Besamim </td></tr><tr> | ||
</tr><tr> <td> Rosemary </td> <td> Atzei Besamim </td> <td> - </td></tr><tr> | </tr><tr> <td> Rosemary </td> <td> Atzei Besamim </td> <td> - </td></tr><tr> | ||
</tr><tr> <td> Tavak </td> <td> No Bracha </td> <td> No Bracha </td></tr><tr> | </tr><tr> <td> Tavak </td> <td> No Bracha </td> <td> No Bracha </td></tr><tr> | ||
</tr><tr> <td> Zatar </td> <td> - </td> <td> | </tr><tr> <td> Zatar </td> <td> - </td> <td> Minei Besamim </td></tr><tr> </table> | ||
==Sources== | ==Sources== | ||
<references/> | <references/> | ||
Revision as of 02:24, 31 May 2013
Just like it is forbidden to benefit from a food without making a Bracha Rishona, it is also forbidden to benefit from a nice smell before making a bracha.[1]
Havdalah
- The Ashkenaz minhag is to make Boreh Minei Besamim (בורא מיני בשמים) which is the general Bracha for nice smells at Havdalavah no matter what’s being used for besamim. However, according to Sephardim, one should make the appropriate Bracha for that besamim. [2]
- During the rest of the week, there’s no argument that there’s a distinction between the following categories:
Boreh Atzei Besamim
- For tree products the Bracha is Boreh Atzei Besamim. Halacha includes any plant (above ground) that has a hard stalk, has leaves, and lasts from year to year. [3]
- Examples of tree products that require Atzei Besamim: Rose, Rosemary, Jasmine, Hadas (myrtle; not on Sukkot), honeysuckle (yellow and white flowery vine) [4]
Boreh Isbei Besamim
- For shrub products the Bracha is Boreh Isbei Besamim. Halacha includes any plant that has a soft stalk or doesn’t last from year to year. [5]
- Examples of shrub products that require Boreh Isbei Besamim: mint, hyacinth, daffodil (certain types). [6]
HaNoten Rayach Tov BaPerot
- For edible fruits that give off a strong smell (from the fruit and not from the peel) the Bracha required is HaNoten Rayach Tov BaPerot. The major limitation of this category is that one should only make the Bracha for a strong smell and only if the fruit is taken to smell and not to eat. [7]
- Examples: Etrog (not on Sukkot), quince, apple, melon [8]
Boreh Minei Besamim
- The general Bracha for nice smells is Boreh Minei Besamim and is made for non-plant or fruit products, or for items for which there’s an unresolved dispute in the poskim. [9]
- Examples: cinnamon, cloves (common for Havdalah ), lemon, hot ground coffee beans (taken to smell), mixture of tree and shrub products. [10]
- For synthetic smells, as is common in cheap perfumes, some say that the Bracha is Boreh Minei Besamim and some say that there’s no Bracha on such a smell. [11]
After the fact
- There’s a dispute whether Bracha of Shehakol covers any Bracha for a nice smell and because of the dispute, after the fact, one may not make another Bracha. [12]
- The Bracha of Atzi doesn’t cover the products that require Isbei and the Bracha of Isbei doesn't cover products that require Atzi. [13]
If one’s in doubt
- If you have a plant which has a nice smell but you personally are in doubt as to whether the Bracha is Atzei or Isbei, if it’s easy to find out the correct Bracha, one should do so, otherwise, one may make Boreh Minei Besamim. (This is different than foods where there’s an obligation to figure out the appropriate halacha instead of making Shehakol.) [14]
- If one is unsure whether a product has a nice or strong smell, one may smell it to check, make the Bracha, and then make the Bracha. [15]
No Bracha
- Certain items have no Bracha including: tavak [16]
- No Bracha is made on a smell that was absorbed or rubbed off a nice smelling product, but now there’s no substance of the Basamim existent. Example: perfume bottle, etrog box, tea leaves. [17]
- No Bracha is made of a nice smelling product that was used to remove a bad smell. For example, one does not make a bracha upon smelling the nice smell of an air freshener in a bathroom. [18]
- The beracha of shehecheyanu is not recited on a fragrance, even those that are renewed each year. [19]
List of Brachot
| Item | Ashkenazim (Vezot HaBracha, Luach Brachot) | Sephardim (Birkat Hashem vol 3) |
| Air freshener (if taken to smell) | No Bracha | Minei Besamim |
| Black pepper | Questionable [20] | Minei Besamim [21] |
| Cinnamon | Minei Besamim | Minei Besamim |
| Cloves | Minei Besamim | Atzei Besamim |
| Daffodil | Isbei Besamim | Minei Besamim |
| Deodorant | Dispute | Minei Besamim |
| Etrog | HaNoten Rayach Tov BeParot | HaNoten Rayach Tov BeParot |
| Ground coffee beans | Minei Besamim | No Bracha |
| Hadas (myrtle) | Atzei Besamim | Atzei Besamim |
| Honeysuckle | Atzei Besamim | - |
| Hyacinth | Isbei Besamim | - |
| Jasmine | Atzei Besamim | - |
| Lemon | Minei Besamim | Minei Besamim |
| Melon | HaNoten Rayach Tov BeParot | - |
| Mint | Isbei Besamim | Isbei Besamim |
| Orange | - | Minei Besamim |
| Quince | HaNoten Rayach Tov BeParot | - |
| Rose | Atzei Besamim | Atzei Besamim |
| Rosemary | Atzei Besamim | - |
| Tavak | No Bracha | No Bracha |
| Zatar | - | Minei Besamim |
Sources
- ↑ Kitzur S"A 58:1
- ↑ Mishna Brurah 297:1, Vezot HaBracha (pg 181, chapter 19)
- ↑ Vezot HaBracha (pg 174, chapter 19)
- ↑ Vezot HaBracha (pg 174, chapter 19)
- ↑ Vezot HaBracha (pg 174, chapter 19)
- ↑ Vezot HaBracha (pg 174, chapter 19)
- ↑ Vezot HaBracha (pg 175, chapter 19)
- ↑ Vezot HaBracha (pg 175, chapter 19)
- ↑ Vezot HaBracha (pg 175-7, chapter 19)
- ↑ Vezot HaBracha (pg 397, Luach Brachot)
- ↑ Vezot HaBracha (pg 182, chapter 19) quotes a dispute between Rav Pinchas Sheinburg who says that synthetic products have a Bracha, and Rav Shlomo Zalman Auerbach who holds that no Bracha is made.
- ↑ Vezot HaBracha (pg 176, chapter 19)
- ↑ Kitzur S"A 58:7, Mishna Brurah 216:39, Vezot HaBracha (pg 176, chapter 19)
- ↑ Kitzur S"A 58:7, Vezot HaBracha (pg 176, chapter 19)
- ↑ Vezot HaBracha (pg 180, chapter 19), Halachically Speaking quoting Ben Ish Chai (VeEtchanan#2).
- ↑ Vezot HaBracha (pg 397, Luach Brachot)
- ↑ Vezot HaBracha (pg 180, chapter 19)
- ↑ Vezot HaBracha (pg 179, chapter 19)
- ↑ Mishna Berura 225:16
- ↑ The Mishna Brurah 297:1 rules that since there is a dispute among the poskim (whether one should make any bracha on it) one shouldn't make a bracha on it. The Vezot HaBracha (pg 179) agrees and adds that due to this dispute one should refrain from smelling it.
- ↑ Kaf HaChaim 297:5, Rav Moshe HaLevi (Menuchat Ahava (vol 1 9:24) and Birkat Hashem (vol 3, 12:17), Ish Matzliach (commentary on Mishna Brurah 297:1)
