Talk:Challah: Difference between revisions
(Created page with "Kol Hakavod to Yitchak Sultan for putting up this picture, but doesn't anyone think it's a little misleading? After all, this page is about the Halachic Challah one must sepa...") |
(→Dough or Flour?: new section) |
||
| (4 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown) | |||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
Kol Hakavod to Yitchak Sultan for putting up this picture, but doesn't anyone think it's a little misleading? After all, this page is about the Halachic Challah one must separate from dough...I know there's no good picture for that, but maybe no picture is better than a misleadng picture? [[User:IvduEsHashemB'Simcha|IvduEsHashemB'Simcha]] ([[User talk:IvduEsHashemB'Simcha|talk]]) 19:49, 25 March 2014 (EDT) | Kol Hakavod to Yitchak Sultan for putting up this picture, but doesn't anyone think it's a little misleading? After all, this page is about the Halachic Challah one must separate from dough...I know there's no good picture for that, but maybe no picture is better than a misleadng picture? [[User:IvduEsHashemB'Simcha|IvduEsHashemB'Simcha]] ([[User talk:IvduEsHashemB'Simcha|talk]]) 19:49, 25 March 2014 (EDT) | ||
I agree that it is a bit misleading. See the new picture. | |||
Regarding the issue of making Challah with the shiur Challah and then freezing some of it and baking it in amounts that aren't the shiur Challah, I heard Rav Hershel Schachter (Brachot Shiur 71 mid-shiur 5778) rule that one can recite the bracha since it is one person kneading it and it is only separated for himself and not separated for other people. Even though it is against Tosfot Brachot 38b we follow the other poskim. | |||
"when majority of Bnei Yisrael reside in Israel" - source? It's not in the Rambam cited as the source, and see section 8 here for a longer discussion https://www.toraland.org.il/מאמרים/המצוות-התלויות-בארץ/שמיטה/מחשבת-השמיטה/רוב-יהודי-העולם-בארץ-ישראל/#_ftn44 | |||
You're correct that the Rambam doesn't say that clearly. | |||
Derech Emunah on Rambam there Bikkurim 5:5 writes that the Rambam doesn't mean davka all of the Jews and a majority is enough. Thank you for the link to the article with a larger discussion of this. I included it in the page. | |||
== Dough or Flour? == | |||
Is this a shiur of flour or of dough? The shiur by Rav Schechter quoted has him saying the shiur of flour, not of dough. Roughly 29 minutes in. --[[User:GFauxPas|GFauxPas]] ([[User talk:GFauxPas|talk]]) 16:41, 15 December 2020 (UTC) | |||
Latest revision as of 16:41, 15 December 2020
Kol Hakavod to Yitchak Sultan for putting up this picture, but doesn't anyone think it's a little misleading? After all, this page is about the Halachic Challah one must separate from dough...I know there's no good picture for that, but maybe no picture is better than a misleadng picture? IvduEsHashemB'Simcha (talk) 19:49, 25 March 2014 (EDT)
I agree that it is a bit misleading. See the new picture.
Regarding the issue of making Challah with the shiur Challah and then freezing some of it and baking it in amounts that aren't the shiur Challah, I heard Rav Hershel Schachter (Brachot Shiur 71 mid-shiur 5778) rule that one can recite the bracha since it is one person kneading it and it is only separated for himself and not separated for other people. Even though it is against Tosfot Brachot 38b we follow the other poskim.
"when majority of Bnei Yisrael reside in Israel" - source? It's not in the Rambam cited as the source, and see section 8 here for a longer discussion https://www.toraland.org.il/מאמרים/המצוות-התלויות-בארץ/שמיטה/מחשבת-השמיטה/רוב-יהודי-העולם-בארץ-ישראל/#_ftn44 You're correct that the Rambam doesn't say that clearly. Derech Emunah on Rambam there Bikkurim 5:5 writes that the Rambam doesn't mean davka all of the Jews and a majority is enough. Thank you for the link to the article with a larger discussion of this. I included it in the page.
Dough or Flour?
Is this a shiur of flour or of dough? The shiur by Rav Schechter quoted has him saying the shiur of flour, not of dough. Roughly 29 minutes in. --GFauxPas (talk) 16:41, 15 December 2020 (UTC)
