Talk:When Does Shabbat End?: Difference between revisions
From Halachipedia
→Contradiction in Rambam about Shiur Mil: new section
(→Contradiction in Rambam about Shiur Mil: new section) |
|||
| Line 22: | Line 22: | ||
* Tanit 12a: The Gra YD 262:9 explains that fundamentally it should be permitted to eat during ben hashemashot of a rabbinic fast day, however, because we follow the opinion of Rabbi Yosi and Rabbi Yosi's ben hashemashot is after Rabbi Yehuda's, it is indeed forbidden to eat during the entire duration of ben hashemashot of Rabbi Yehuda. | * Tanit 12a: The Gra YD 262:9 explains that fundamentally it should be permitted to eat during ben hashemashot of a rabbinic fast day, however, because we follow the opinion of Rabbi Yosi and Rabbi Yosi's ben hashemashot is after Rabbi Yehuda's, it is indeed forbidden to eat during the entire duration of ben hashemashot of Rabbi Yehuda. | ||
* Shabbat 21b: Maharam Alshaker 96 and Gra dispute Rabbenu Tam's assumption about the language משתקע החמה. They say that the language in fact implies the beginning of shekiya and say that one should light at the beginning of shekiya. They don't directly address the issue of lighting while it is light outside. | * Shabbat 21b: Maharam Alshaker 96 and Gra dispute Rabbenu Tam's assumption about the language משתקע החמה. They say that the language in fact implies the beginning of shekiya and say that one should light at the beginning of shekiya. They don't directly address the issue of lighting while it is light outside. | ||
== Contradiction in Rambam about Shiur Mil == | |||
Orot Chaim p. 339 answers for the Rambam that in fact the real shiur mil is 18 minutes as he writes in Brachot 1:1 and the reason he works with the 24 minute mil in Pesachim 9:1 and Korban Pesach 5:8 is because that is based on walking slowly. The Rambam in fact mentions that the walking for that 15 mil is measured by walking slowly. | |||
